Saturday, December 10th, 2011 at 5:17 pm  |  42 responses

Game Notes: The 2011 Crosstown Shootout

Xavier’s heads bloodied but unbowed after brawl-infested victory over Cincinnati.

by Eddie Maisonet / @edthesportsfan

The No. 8 team in the country did what it was supposed to do to a team in disarray, as the Xavier Musketeers played arguably their best game of the season and dismantled the Cincinnati Bearcats 76-53 in the 2011 edition of the Crosstown Shootout. Xavier out-manned, out-flanked, and straight up ambushed Cincinnati at the Cintas Center, as the dynamic back court of Tu Holloway (17 points, 6 assists) and Mark Lyons (19 points, 4 assists) proved too tough for Mick Cronin’s team. While Yancy Gates put up 18 points and 12 rebounds for the Bearcats, his squad never had a consistent answer for Xavier’s defense and ability to get to the rim.

Of course, that’s not what folks will remember from this game, so let me get out some of the obvious stuff now.

After a full 24 hours (that we can account for) of jawing back and forth, late in the fourth quarter the brawl broke out. From what started since the tip of the game, to Mark Lyons jawing with the entire Bearcats bench towards the end of the first half during play, to the end shenanigans with the leader of the Muskies Tu Holloway squared up with Ge’Lawn Guyn, a bench player for the Bearcats.

We’ll never know the words that were exchanged between the two, and truthfully it doesn’t matter. What happened next does, when Guyn mushed Holloway in the face and chaos ensued.

You do anything harmful to an opposing team’s star player, expect some retribution to come your way. Maybe Holloway deserved it after yapping with the other team, but like in any situation where trash talk is prevalent and competition against your rival, don’t dish out what you can’t handle in return. As soon as Guyn mushed Holloway, freshman Dezmine Wells pushed Guyn off his teammate and the Xavier roster rode to defend their captain

That’s what a team is supposed to do, rally behind their captain.

So yes, some folks will point to Xavier center Kenny Frease getting chin-checked by Yancy Gates as a sign of being soft or getting some type of revenge. Hitting someone in the face while they’re trying to break-up a fight is pretty cowardly, and while having a black eye and needing a few stitches will cause temporary pain there can be a supreme sense of satisfaction knowing you caused someone to resort to throwing a punch while dealing with a 23-point loss to your rival as a senior.

Of course, one would (and should) question Xavier head coach Chris Mack for having his best players in the game with a 20+ point lead. Maybe he was allowing his seniors to relish in the victory, but as my good buddy Ken said quite eloquently, “A coach, of all the folks on the floor not named refs, has to be able to gauge the temperature of the floor. Mack didn’t.”

With a game that heated, with the magnitude of the rivalry and playing in a hostile environment, Mack has to know better.

So how do we feel about this Xavier team now? An 8-0 record with a No. 8 ranking in the national polls and a demonstrative victory over a quality Big East team should make us believe that this team is legit to make a serious run…right? You’ll hear that this game is a blemish on Tu Holloway’s legacy at Xavier, that Mark Lyons is a goon and other things that don’t really matter.

What matters is that this Xavier might have the one thing that we don’t usually expect to see from top teams from big time conferences….toughness.

“They were disrespecting us before the game. One of their guys called me out and said I couldn’t start for them. I was saying, ‘This is my city here.’ One of their guys put his hands in my face,” Holloway said. “We’re a bunch of gangsters, but we’re not thugs. We’re tough guys. We’re not gonna let someone else kick our face in.”

Yes, suspensions will be handed down. Discipline will be enforced. Chastising will occur. Coach Mack will let his team have it, but I’d bet there’s a bit of encouragement in seeing his team this unified. When things get tough you either stand tall or you stand down. Xavier stood tall against a rival who is perceived to be bigger and tougher, but not on this day. Holloway, Lyons, Wells and the rest of the Xavier squad took the bully’s best punch and will be better off for it in the long run. Even with a black eye.

  • Add a Comment
  • Share
  • RSS

Tags: , ,

  • Enigmatic Posted: Dec.10 at 5:55 pm
    Great write up, I was looking forward to reading this recap since you mentioned it on Twitter.
    I’m really glad you pointed out that Guyn mushed Holloway and then Wells pushed Guyn.
    Seems like everyone at ESPN missed that and wanted to point the finger at Wells cause they only saw the push and missed mush (did I really just type that?).
    You gotta think Yancy Gates’ career at Cincy is over now. What a horrible way to end it, seems like dude has been at Cincy forever. But that was some foul stuff, sucker-punching Fries, and then some other kid stomped him out too like it was China/G Town all over again!
    This should get interesting. I hope Tu Holloway won’t be disciplined too hard, as this is looking like it might be Xavier’s best season since David West was a senior there.

  • jdote Posted: Dec.10 at 5:58 pm
    “We’re a bunch of gangsters but we’re not thugs.” Worst collegiate athlete quote I’ve heard in a long time. It won’t matter though cuz its not a Kentucky or Duke guy saying it but wow. Are those the athletes yall stress should be paid.

  • ben osborne Posted: Dec.10 at 5:59 pm
    Nice write up of what seems like a wild game. Thanks for being there for us, Ed.

  • Enigmatic Posted: Dec.10 at 6:39 pm
    Oh, it’ll matter that Holloway said that.
    Xavier is not Kentucky or Duke but they’re still a top ten team and Holloway is an All-American.
    I think the post game comments will cause them to be suspended even more games.

  • thedirtyharry Posted: Dec.10 at 8:18 pm
    Didn’t we see this in the NBA not too long ago. Why don’t we have rules that suspend players who leave their seats or go out of their way to engage in taunting or bullying. When the coaches and refs fail to do their jobs things like this happen. Freeze and Yates had no reason to be off their seats. 10 game suspension for all of them is in appropriate.

  • shutup Posted: Dec.10 at 9:38 pm
    If I got knocked out swelled up and bloodied I wouldnt have gotten up talking sh!t and it wasnt a sucker punch, what do you think happens when you act tough and get in someones face?

  • Enigmatic Posted: Dec.10 at 10:02 pm
    Frease wasn’t acting tough and getting in anyone’s face, he was trying to break up the fight, wasnt even looking at Gates’ direction and didn’t even see Gates come from the side and deck him.
    So yeah, it was a sucker punch. Followed up by a sucker kick.
    I tell you what though, Lyons has got some balls.
    That kid was all up in Gates’ face, fearless despite Gates being 6’9″, 260 and he’s only 6’1″, 190.

  • Losers Posted: Dec.10 at 11:29 pm
    Wow. Your team behaves like utter clowns and you guys are all smiles. Thismismamtrash team, with trash fans dealing trash insults. And you writenthentrasj as if there is some honor in it. This was a pathetic display of stupidity and selfishness. And then there was the players.

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 12:22 am
    pushing your way through a battlefield because your big, isnt acting tough? You claim to know what his intentions are, all i saw was him rushing towards the opposing team. I dont cosign the kick, but to get punched square in the jaw, thats his own fault, as for that fearless stuff the coaches were already in between them, looked comical to me.

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 12:24 am
    oh and btw it was xaviers players fault for acting an a$$ first and they initiated the fight by pushing,unless you wanna call that a sucker push too?

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 12:26 am
    oh and if you watch the video again gates was standing in front off him while he was pushing forward sidestepped and tagged him,i dont see how thats a sucker punch

  • Enigmatic Posted: Dec.11 at 2:29 am
    We’ll have to agree to disagree. I still see a sucker punch.
    Can’t put the blame on one team or one player.
    I didn’t just watch the video, I saw the whole game on tv and I knew one of the Cincy players was talking sh*t about Tu Holloway on local radio saying Holloway wouldn’t even start if he played for Cincinnati, and they were jawing all game long so it’s about a lot more than just what you see on the video.

  • Enigmatic Posted: Dec.11 at 2:39 am
    And pushing your way through “cause you’re big” is acting tough?
    Sh*t, have you ever been in a brawl?
    Have you ever been in a situation where you had to grab your boys and separate them from other cats or jump in and get their backs?
    Did you push your way through?
    Or did you say some “pardon me sir, I must help and or escort my friends”?
    F*ck that.
    You’re gonna bumrush that sh*t, and if you’re a big guy that don’t mean you’re acting like a tough guy.
    That just means people are gonna assume you think you’re a tough guy cause of your size.
    Case in point ^

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 3:12 am
    im a bouncer at a las vegas night club yeah ive seen some brawls, but when you act tough like that thats what happens, if your gonna go into the fire for your boys “protect yourself at all times” from what i saw he didnt try to grab his boys he tried to confront someone else, he was pushing not pulling. and i just think maybe the fight was outta his element, like he never saw a real scuffle before and thats what ultimately led to him getting tagged.
    i can vibe with the agree to disagree, i heard about all the trash talking, but i put blame on xavier squad because they won or were winning, take the W and do it with dignity.

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 3:15 am
    an upon watchin the video again I only saw Cincy players in front of him when he got hit, either way as entertaining as fights are, it just sucks that people could lose their scholarships

  • Enigmatic Posted: Dec.11 at 3:58 am
    Yeah, I could see that he might have jumped into a situation he had never been in.
    And with adrenaline pumping and everything happening so fast, dude was unprepared and got tagged.
    I think more than the players, ultimately the Xavier coach has to take some responsibility too cause theres just no sense in keeping your best players in a game where you’re up by 20 in a hostile environment

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 4:29 am
    thats exactly what i was thinking, maybe the refs shoulda stepped in earlier seeing as the team was winning already if they woulda called a tech it woulda defused the situation

  • Blucat Posted: Dec.11 at 1:16 pm
    I’ll never look at Xavier the same. Their fans have portrayed Cincinnati as thugs, and XU as a classy program that does things right, and recruits a different type of player. Wrong. Tu Holloway: “we got a bunch of gangstas in our locker room.” No matter the ranking, X is just another thug program. Reminds me of some Georgetown teams of yesteryear, only not as good.

  • gradXU Posted: Dec.11 at 1:50 pm
    Whoever let TU and Lyons talk to media should be fired.
    “A bunch of gangstas”….???
    “Zip them up” [in body bags]?????
    Where is the coaching? the leadership? the guidance for young men who clearly don’t have the skills or experience to survive in society after basketball?
    This is a disgrace, and, unfortunately,equal blame must be placed on the XU team and coaching staff. EVERYONE should be lining up to support Cronin’s statements and to encourage severe sanctions for both teams.

  • JTaylor21 Posted: Dec.11 at 2:43 pm
    All I know is that no one has a problem when there are brawls in baseball and hockey but as soon as there’s a fight in a sport dominated by blacks, everyone treats it like WWIII.
    Also, f*ck racists.

  • JB Posted: Dec.11 at 3:01 pm
    Suspensions? What about expulsion from the universities? If these were students who were not basketball players, they would be gone immediately.

  • niQ Posted: Dec.11 at 3:17 pm
    There was a replay on youtube that showed the Yancy Gates punch in slow motion. Clearly it was a sucker punch as Frease wasn’t even looking his way. And yes, like Enigmatic said, Frease was trying to break up the fight.

  • HS1 Posted: Dec.11 at 4:28 pm
    “Coach Mack will let his team have it, but I’d bet there’s a bit of encouragement in seeing his team this unified.” Are you kidding me? This is how you report this pathetic mess? No wonder so-called sports in the US are all about money and greed. Sport is supposed to be uplifting. There is meant to be ‘sportsmanship’, remember that? These players are just hoodlums, or ‘gangstas’ as ringleader and all round cretin Tu Holloway stated at the end of the game. That’s not unity, it’s like a bar fight only without the excuse of alcohol. And this is college sports, for crying out loud! Where were the coaches and the officials? Basketball fights, baseball strikes, criminal convictions…. what a bunch of overpaid losers….sheesh!

  • Enigmatic Posted: Dec.11 at 5:05 pm
    The suspensions are laughable. Yancy Gates got the worst of it with 6 games.
    JTaylor, I agree with you when it comes to professional sports.
    I hate when people think NHL fights and bench clearing brawls in MLB are cool but then wanna label players thugs or ghetto after an NBA fight.
    But when it comes to college sports I don’t think ANYONE in ANY sport has any business getting into a fight, ever.
    And I think if they do they should be disciplined, maybe even kicked out of school.
    I mean, if Yancy Gates was an average student who punched another dude he would’ve been arrested and possibly kicked out of school.
    Instead he’ll be back playing in time for when conference play gets really good.

  • JTaylor21 Posted: Dec.11 at 6:13 pm
    JTaylor, I have to disagree. College cats have more rights to be heated and possible fight than Pros because they are basically playing and making the NCAA/Colleges billions of dollars for free. I know I’ll be on edge every day knowing that my hardwork is the reason why coaches and DA’s are living in million dollar mansions and driving benzes while I’m holed up in a tiny a** apartment.
    Also, don’t you think that destroying Gates’ college career and possible graduation (he’s a senior) is too harsh of a punishment for a petty sucker-punch? No way am I defending his actions but kicking him out of school for something that occurred on a basketball court is a little too much. I understand if the coach kicks him off the team but the man should be allowed to finish his education.

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 6:16 pm
    in the nhl the guys that get into fights are called goons. goons/thugs same difference. fighting is permitted in hockey, its in the rule book so that comparison doesnt work. Baseball somehow gets a pass, i dont understand that. people get into fights on campus all the time and receive little to know punishment. a battery charge for a first time offender is a fine and some community service. I’m glad no one lost their scholarships, if only for the reason that it gives them a chance to continue their education, but i do think the suspensions should of been longer.
    if you just look at the punch its easy to take out of context, Frease was entering the fray blindly, I dont think he was expecting any resistance, Gates was already in a defensive posture (hands balled up in a attacking stance) maybe Frease shoulda been aware of his surroundings, pushing forward into enemy territory by yourself is never a good idea. I think the biggest suspension should go to the player that kicked him while he was down, and the two xavier guards that showed no remorse or contrition after the events. I’m the first one to argue against racist comments, look at my track record…. but if you want people to stop perpetuating stereotypes; stop acting like said stereotypes. he called his own team a bunch of thugs btw

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 6:19 pm
    is jtaylor disagreeing with himself? im confused

  • Enigmatic Posted: Dec.11 at 10:10 pm
    That’s exactly what I was gonna say.
    JTaylor has finnalt lost it.
    Looking at his reflection in the mirror going “I’m not crazy, you’re crazy!” LOL

  • shutup Posted: Dec.11 at 11:18 pm
    lmao, i had to reread it like 6 times, at least his disagreement with himself was civil, when i argue with myself it gets real ugly start calling each other’s mothers names and shyt

  • BBaller Posted: Dec.12 at 12:53 am
    In the heat of the moment, fierce rivalry, things happen. What was the most ugly display was once the players calmed down and then unbelievably did the post game interview, no remorse was shown. “We’re grown men” well act like it. “We’re gangstas” f$ck’n please, you are spoiled athletes who have had your ego patted for too long. ” he called me out” how childish. They are not hard or tough, just ego maniacs.The suspensions were soft and Frease should charge Yates with Assault and Battery.

  • BBaller Posted: Dec.12 at 12:54 am
    ^Gates

  • shutup Posted: Dec.12 at 5:04 am
    beating a dead horse here but watch the video Frease initiated the contact, he grabbed his jersey. gates could claim self defense. Frease moving forward, Gates standing stationary maybe even back pedaling, im just saying

  • bike Posted: Dec.12 at 3:45 pm
    The brawl was bad enough, but the postgame behavior of guys like Holloway was the worst. Using terms like ‘gangsta’ and acting like you have no regrets about what went down is a good way to bring your college career to an end. This has nothing to do with toughness, it was a game that the refs and coaches let get out of hand.
    How this writer comes to the conclusion that Mack will view this scuffle as a sign of unified behavior on his team is beyond comprehension.

  • T-Ray Posted: Dec.13 at 1:34 am
    Am I the only one who saw Yates say “I drop n*ggas!” I was cracking up laughing lmao

  • JBV Posted: Dec.13 at 5:26 am
    “Hitting someone in the face while they’re trying to break-up a fight is pretty cowardly”
    my thoughts exactly.

  • [...] then, with nine seconds left, the brawl broke out. We’ll never know the words that were exchanged between the two and truthfully, it doesn’t [...]

  • A Duggins Posted: Dec.13 at 10:11 pm
    Tu Holloway:
    “We got disrespected a little bit before the game, guys calling us out. We’re a tougher team. We’re grown men over here. We got a whole bunch of gangstas in the locker room, not thugs but tough guys on the court. We went out there and zipped ‘em up at the end of the game.” Choice of words could have been thought out better, but I’m pretty sure every coach in America wants his players to be “tough.” You’re not going to win many college basketball games if you’re not tough.
    Maybe, if he had said warriors instead of gangstas, he might not have offended the easily offended. I’m not up on the latest in youth slang and don’t know how prevalent the use of “gangstas” is, but I think I can easily extract his meaning without getting my panties in a bunch, especially since he immediately clarified what he meant by it!
    Now, as a combat veteran, I don’t particularly appreciate the zipping ‘em up comment if, indeed, it’s referring to body bags.

  • shutup Posted: Dec.14 at 4:05 am
    how do you know he was trying to break up the fight? you just assume that was his intention while pushing two players not on his team.

  • DieselMechanic Posted: Dec.14 at 8:57 am
    Mark Lyons is by far the most confident person I’ve ever met in my life. I predicted he’d have a breakout year before the season started.

  • Allenp Posted: Dec.14 at 5:13 pm
    I never understood the whole “sucker punch” thing.
    I mean, if somebody hits you from behind, yeah, that’s cowardly.
    But, if you’re facing each other, and you decide to look away or whatever and get tagged. Or if somebody just punches you without warning while y’all are facing each other, why is that considered cowardly.
    Are you required to announce your punches? Doesn’t that seem like a good way to lose the fight?

  • Larry C Posted: Dec.15 at 4:04 am
    I get the whole he shoulda been prepared for the sucka punch diving into the middle. But then I was thinking so you should go to a Basketball game prepared for a punch, what the H*)), I can’t believe this is what sports has come to now, you should come to a game prepared to fight or recieve a punch. Yea great role models better yet with the cost of tuition is that the kind of athlete my tax dollars are paying for with full ride scholarships. I don’t want it not even one part of it. First of all Xavier act like you’ve won a game before, UC take the butt wiping and let it fuel your preparation for the rest of this season and next till you play again!!!

  • reflective one Posted: Jan.10 at 1:29 pm
    How do you like ‘em (the Musketeers) now?

Comments




The comments section is a place to further discuss the topics in this post. Commenters who seek to accomplish any of the following may be banned: - Personally attack other commenters. - Make derogatory comments regarding race, ethnicity, language, gender, sexual orientation or religion. - Troll, or comment with the intention of creating problems. Trolling includes, but isn't limited to, baiting people to flame at you, encouraging people to leave the site, spamming and using alternate IDs.