Monday, November 23rd, 2009 at 3:30 pm  |  36 responses

The (Next) Great Position Battle Royal

Small forward is the new power forward.

by Brad GrahamTim Duncan

You’re only as good as your competition, right? It’s because of this rationale that the NBA will be governed by the multi-faceted small forward during the millenniums second decade. One would think that thanks to LeBron James this is an easy deduction to make. Not so fast. Of course this simple revelation wouldn’t be possible without the poster child, aka the King of Cleveland, ruling the NBA’s various landscapes.

The Naughties gave the NBA’s power forward position the perfect platform to take center stage (remember that “you’re only as good as your competition” cliché, guess what, it rang true) as Tim Duncan, Kevin Garnett, Dirk Nowitzki, Rasheed Wallace, Chris Webber, Carlos Boozer, Amar’e Stoudemire, Jermaine O’Neal, Elton Brand, Chris Bosh and Pau Gasol went to war, paint ball (pun intended) style.

Taking shots at one another, these basketball lords led their respective franchises to everything from regular season excellence to conference and NBA Finals appearances. This was coupled with countless individual awards of the Week, Month, All NBA, Rookie and MVP (regular season, All-Star and Finals) variety.

Need more proof? Remember those mid decade Western Conference All-Star teams that were so over flowing with PF aptitude that your favorite NBA athlete was more often than not found watching the mid-season classic from the comfort of their own lounge room despite their All-Star caliber of play? That didn’t happen by accident. More so, the NBA’s 30 Head Coaches can’t all be wrong, year after year, can they? Even if the numbers lie, surely they don’t.

As influential as these glass cleaning, college skipping, Euro invading and bank shot making machines were, they didn’t exactly rise above all comers. This brings up the most important historical trend of the past 20 years: The counterweight. Whenever there’s a trend, there has been an exception. Someone out to spoil the iKobe Bryantnvite only party… a cooler and more desirable gate crasher if you will.

While these superior PFs battled all decade long like a pack of hungry jackals in the Kalahari, a polarizing shooting guard from the Los Angeles Lakers named Kobe Bryant dominated (and hogged) headlines, creating a snake (both the Black Mamba and “evil” kind) to became the definitive and most memorable individual NBA player of the decade. Don’t worry, it gets better…

Of course, this NBA counterpoint has never been more evident than in the 1990s as his Airness, Michael Jordan, became the ballast to a decade dominated by oversized pivot enforcers. It’s for this reason that the ‘90s remains the most multifarious and conflicting era of pro basketball. Despite Hakeem Olajuwon, David Robinson, Shaquille O’Neal, Patrick Ewing, Dikembe Mutombo and Alonzo Mourning all earning their respective right to be feared, the season ending hardware was rarely enjoyed by these impressively super sized athletes. It wasn’t bad enough that the C position didn’t take over, as expected, but then it proved it couldn’t sell sneakers as well, gosh, talk about falling short (but it’s best not to digress, again).

Fast forward back to the contemporary NBA and that next decade scale tipper could be Public Relations dream boat Dwight Howard or the equally likable 2010 free agent Dwyane Wade. Guess what, that’ll never work, neither one is as popular or magnetic/repulsive as Kobe or MJ, not yet anyway… speaking of decade long dominance, one could easily (but foolishly) argue that upcoming scenes from the NBA Next Gen’s mini-series will be directed by the L’s floor generals. Once again, think again.

While perennial playmakers Chris Paul, Deron Williams, Derrick Rose, Brandon Jennings, Devin Harris and Jonny Flynn (plus the soon to be drafted John Wall), all look capable of changing the game like a Jay-Z album, it’s easy to mistake their entertaining but creative showing for a masterful stroke, don’t worry, it happens all the time, and not just in sport but in all forms of art too, how do we know, history tells us so.

There are only two problems with handing the PG position the title of the next decade’s definitive position. A. As any true hoop enthusiast knows, it’s highly unlikely that any of these skilled cats will challenge both Jason Kidd and/or two time NBA MVP Steve Nash on the Top 10 all-time point guard list, let alone surpass them both (sorry CP3 fans, he may come close when it’s all said and done but lets not loose our collective head and hand out historically significant titles like they’re IHOP coupons).

(Side note: for the record, the 10 greatest NBA PGs, in no particular order, are: Tiny Archibald, Gary Payton, Walt Frazier, Jason Kidd, Steve Nash, Bob Cousy, John Stockton, Oscar Robertson, Isiah Thomas and Magic Johnson. How do we know this, ESPN told us so (and their panel of experts are just that). Without forcing a fan to over think this too much, who would you honestly remove from that PG list to make room for CP3? Not nearly as easy as it looks, is it?)

Getting back to business… B. If you’re going to have positional dominance, one player from that deep crop needs to challenge for a spot on the all-time starting five, hence how and why they instantly elevate the competition of their position, there goes that “You’re only as good as your competition” saying again. See: Duncan, Tim (‘00s) and Olajuwon, Hakeem (’90s) for more evidence. Which brings us full circle back to that number 6-, er… 23-wearing athlete known simply as LBJ.

It makes senKevin Durantse that the upcoming decade (aka the Teenies) is setting itself up for small forward dominance. Although this rests logically and largely on the broad shoulders of King James, he’s joined by fellow 2003 draftee, Carmelo Anthony and Oklahoma City Thunder gunner Kevin Durant but it doesn’t end with this electrifying trio at the three, otherwise it wouldn’t challenge the PFs of this decade, now would it? Joining the procession to ensure the SF torch is carried for years to come is the dynamic Joe Johnson (a true SF who simply refuses to play conventionally, like he’s been bitten by the Dirk Nowitzki bug) and young Indiana Pacer Danny Granger. That’s five three’s to watch in 2010 and beyond.

It’s becoming clear that Paul Pierce’s tank will hit E before the next decade runs the table, eliminating him from discussion. More interesting though is the yet to be delivered verdict by the court of public opinion on both young studs Trevor Ariza and Anthony Randolph, who could either be all real deal or the real fill. There’s Rashard Lewis’ proven track record but he remains out of sight (largely because Dwight’s smile blinds all on lookers while his biceps continually gang up on Lewis, forcing him to spend money from his mega contract on body enhancing drugs).

So much of this SF projection, however, hinges on the potential showing of super studs Rudy Gay, Thaddeus Young and Michael Beasley, all of whom are impending talents, set to come into their own as elite NBA athletes in the coming season(s). Plus, looking further ahead, if the Harrison Barnes hype machine is to be believed, the basketball world might be looking to add his name to the fold within five years.

What this boils down to is the top names (KD, Melo and LBJ) are once in a generation type talents unlike the PGs who simply are excellent. Scottie Pippen and Larry Bird, respectively, have long been regarded as the greatest SF’s in the game but LBJ’s (not to mention Melo’s and Durant’s) unlimited capacity, multiplied by his natural ability, hunger and billion dollar delusions dreams set him up to surpass them both. That’s what elevates this group of SFs as the decade defining class. There’s no guarantee that they’ll ever get there but they’re in the best shape of any starting position and the same can’t be said for the PGs, as gifted as they already are/can be.

In short, when it comes to the SF, we haven’t seen influence, vigor and proficiency since, well, last decade when the PF crew (led by KG, Dirk and Duncan) reminded us all that basketball’s checklist is forever being rewritten.

Brad Graham is a hoop culture aficionado attempting to flee the once proud Australian basketball scene. He can be reached via email at brad.graham.creative@gmail.com.

  • Add a Comment
  • Share
  • RSS

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

  • http://www.in-n-outnba.blogspot.com Lucas

    This is so true, including guys in high school right now who are going to be GREAT.

  • Hoodsnake

    Nice article but that Rashard comment was a bit below the belt

  • http://slamonline.com/ niQ

    I liked the Paint Ball pun. Never heard of that before. Good read still!

  • Joe King

    HOw the hell did oscar robertson average a triple double a season from the point..

    GOAT?

  • Dagger

    Joe King: because of the much faster pace of the game, the relative lack of defence and the fact that he was playing against much shorter, less athletic competition.

  • LA Huey

    Wow, just Bird and Pip? Wasn’t Iceman an SF too?

  • Easy-E

    Hmmmm, that CP3 dig hurt me a bit; because I’m a fan and he’s got numbers to rival some of those dudes. But he doesn’t have the hardware….

    I get it…

  • J

    when you put The Big O in the SG spot, he’s still top 10 all time, same if you put him on SF.. that’s how great he is..

  • http://www.alllooksame.com Tarzan Cooper

    PLEASE, for chrissakes take steve nash off that list! what has he done? he didnt really become an nba player until 2001. his numbers are greatly inflated with his teams style. however, his shooting numbers are totally legit. his back to back mvps are the biggest joke in the history of the nba. get lucid!

  • http://www.alllooksame.com Tarzan Cooper

    i completely agree with the thesis of this piece. rudy is set to join bron melo and durantula.

  • J

    ^don’t forget that Danny Granger guy.. he’s a total legit.

  • http://antwonomous.blogspot.com Antwonomous

    Joe Johnson was a reach, though.

  • J

    ^ Johnson was more of a SG to me

  • karan

    SF position is great at the top but not deep. I think it is the PG position that will truly dictate NBA success in the “teenies”. CP3, Deron, Tony Parker, Rondo, Rose, Jennings, Tyreke Evans, Ricky Rubio, Devin Harris, Jonny Flynn, and later John Wall… the depth of talent in this position will be much more than the SFs of the future

  • http://nicekicks.com MeloMan2.0

    @Tarzan: no matter what his team plays like, how can u deny him of being a good player, even a HOFer?? whether u think he deserved it or not, he still has 2 mvp’s (more than kobe) so recognize greatness when u see it

  • rainman10

    Any basketball purist knows that Steve Nash is one of the greatest players and point guards ever. You have to know the game and watch the game to understand that. Maybe Kobe should have gotten that 2nd MVP of Nash’s, but then again Duncan stole an MVP from Kidd in my opinion. One of the top 3 PGs to ever run the pick and roll, almost to the point of revolutionizing the play. His athleticism is unmatched by anyone in the league, Kobe is real close though.

  • http://nicekicks.com MeloMan2.0

    lebron stole the roy award from melo also…

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    Ice was more of a shooting guard, I think.

  • http://www.slamonline.com Wayno

    LeBron won the ROY award his first day in the league…it didn’t matter if Melo played better than him that season. I was rooting for Melo to win it too.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    The 90′s remains one of (if not the) best decade in basketball history. On one hand, you had great centers in Patrick Ewing, Dream Olajuwon, Admiral Robinson, Alonzo, and Deke Mutombo. On the other, you had some of the greatest/coolest shooting guards ever in Michael Jordan, Reggie Miller, Mitch Richmond, Latrell Sprewell, John Starks, Penny Hardaway (who could play anything), Sean Elliot, Vernon Maxwell, etc.
    Then you had the great powerforwards of all time, as well as Bernard King’s miraculous comeback from injury (one of the game’s greatest Small Forwards).
    Then you had the great rivalries, such as Bulls/Knicks, Knicks/Pacers, Rockets/Spurs, Bulls/Blazers, Knicks/Heat etc.
    Then you had some of the coolest teams of all time, in the Blue Collar REAL New York Knicks, the Champion Bulls, the Dream Team Rockets, RUN TMC, the Greg Ostertag Utah Jazz, the SEATTLE Supersonics, the Mutombo Denver Nuggets, the Penny Hardaway and Young-Skilled-Athletic-Shaquille O’Neal Orlando Magic, the Miller/Rose/Dunking Dutch Pacers, the birth of the Toronto Raptors and Miami Heat, the 8th-seeded Knicks team that made the finals, and many more.
    What a great decade in basketball, on all facets of the game.

  • jumpman3224

    Bird and Pippen…best SFs? Bird number one for sure, but what about Elgin? Dr. J? I’d say both of those guys over Pip.

  • don

    LMAO on the lewis’ line.

  • Da Hood

    Thank you, wtf u ppl just dont know what Elgin Baylor did for the game, but Mike G. is going set these teens and twenties ON FIRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Easily!

  • http://www.slamonline.com Wayno

    co-sign teddy there, although I’d add the last half of the 80′s to that too. Like 1985-2000 is the best period of NBA basketball IMO.

  • http://www.slamonline.com Charles Peach

    Great stuff, as usual, Brad. Looking forward to following your blog!

  • http://www.twitter.com/Th3_R3al_Chris Th3_R3al_Chris

    I think the author here is undermining the point guards of today’s NBA. It’s been about 14 years since the NBA has had THIS MANY borderline-great Point Guards.

  • http://IJustWantMyNameToLookBig.com Chukaz

    Why bring Lewis into this? Ain’t he like 30? Joe Johnson’s a sg and he pretty old too. I think he like 28, no?

  • http://www.sonicbids.com doyouwantmore

    This article could have been pared down a few thousand words to: “Here’s all the stars. Lebron James is probably the best, and the other guys that are the best are small forwards or shooting guards, so Power Forwards are not as important.”

  • http://www.facebook.com 9Steele9

    yes, doyouwantmore, the entire paper does boil down to a thesis. so does every piece of writing, ever.

    you got his thesis wrong, too.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    Elgin Baylor = Top 3 Small Forwards ever.

  • http://myspace.com/rsaenz24 RoG23

    Lebron, melo, durant, gay, b-easy, butler, granger, j-howard, prince, josh smith, gerald wallace iguodala (sometimes)….. Maybees: ariza, thorton, randolph, wilson, morrison…..yes I still have hope!

  • Sour Milk

    Nash is def a top 10PG, 9th if you rank them: Magic, O, Zeke, Stockton, Clyde, Kidd, Tiny, Cousy, Nash, Payton. SFs go: Bird, Baylor, Dr. J, Hondo, Rick Barry, Pippen, Lebron (yes already), ‘Nique, English, Dantley…. Monorable Mention: Cunningham, Aguirre, King, Mullin, Worthy. Gervin was a 2-guard. As for this article, James will be one of the all time greats, Melo will be a HOFer too, as goes for KD i think, Granger, Gay, etc. not sure, doesn’t smell great too me… plus, JJ plays the 2 in ATL, Rashard plays an unconventional 4. Beasley’s true position is PF and will always be, same for Randolph…

  • Sour Milk

    and I’m sick of hearing the “good because of the system” BS argument. Which star doesn’t play in a system that plays on the star’s strenghts (see: Iverson, Allen)? And if you’re going to use it, why hasn’t Chris Duhon’s name been mentioned in MVP discussions? Nash is and has been a great player. Iverson’s finals team in Philly played upon his strenghts, but I still regard him an all-time great…

  • J

    Sour Milk: i agree on your list but i think you might want to reconsider your SF list and put King on it and not just on the honorable mentions. BK was a monster when healthy and still very solid when hurt. remember that detroit-knicks series?

  • Sour Milk

    True, but English and Dantley were just so damn solid over such a long time. English putting up 30ppg well past the age of 30. Before my time but you could make a case for Pitchin’ Paul Arizin as a top 10 SF as well, and Cunningham might just be a PF, only it’s difficult to consider players from that era regarding positions as they were less defined… Lebron will be the number 1 or 2 SF of all time when it’s all said and done. However personally I don’t always get the positional differences, and some coaches (Pop, Frank, Spoelstra)even say they don’t consider it 5 different positions, but just, normally, a point guard, two wings and two posts. The key is complementing each other…

  • Ed LOmax

    Please remove Gary Payton from the Top 10 PG’s of all time. You’ve got to be kidding me?

Advertisement