Friday, February 4th, 2011 at 11:31 am  |  17 responses

LA to L.A. Rejected

Duncan’s lifetime achievement award nixes Aldridge’s All-Star bid.

by Chris Haynes / @ChrisBhaynes

No doubt, Tim Duncan is arguably the best power forward to ever walk the face of the earth. But he’s not the best this year. Duncan was voted on to the 2011 All-Star team as a reserve by the coaches, excluding the likes of LaMarcus Aldridge, Kevin Love and Monta Ellis.

I understand that the San Antonio Spurs have the NBA’s best record and the coaches probably felt like at least two Spurs deserved to be on the squad. Then again, there’s another Spurs candidate who is more deserving, Tony Parker.

Parker is averaging 17.3 points per game to go along with 6.8 assist per game, opposed to Duncan’s 13.9 ppg and 9.4 rpg. Parker is still in the prime of his career while Duncan’s game has deteriorated immensely.

Aldridge should have received the All-Star bid instead of Duncan. You can make the same case for Love also, but, my reasoning comes down to facts and stats.

Head-to-head, January 17, against the Minnesota Timberwolves, Aldridge won the game and match-up against Love going for 37 and 12 to Love’s 22 and 17. January 20, nationally televised game, Aldridge leads the Portland Trail Blazers to victory over the Los Angeles Clippers. Aldridge finishes with 28 and 8 while Blake Griffin ended with 20 and 18 off of 6-17 from the field. Then, to really make my case, Tuesday night Aldridge exploded for a 40-point ,11-rebound performance in a rout of the Spurs. Duncan finished with 15 and 7.

In the wining days, Aldridge went up against the top power forwards who challenged his All-Star invite and not only did he win the individual battles, he went 3-0 during those contest.

Other notable snubs such as Ellis, Steve Nash, Eric Gordon to name a few, are in the discussion, but there has to be something said for being on a Playoff-contending team such as the Blazers.

We’ve often ridiculed the fans for not selecting the right All-Star starters. We’ve questioned if the fans had the know-how to select the 10 best players at each position. The fans got it right this time — aside from the Yao Ming selection, as the coaches decided to turn their vote into a lifetime achievement award.

What Aldridge has done since Brandon Roy went out with a knee injury has been simply sensational. He’s averaging 25 ppg and 10 rpg during the absence of Roy as teams have been forced to game-plan for the emergence of Aldridge on the block to no avail. The Blazers are hanging on to that final Playoff spot and Aldridge is the main reason why.

At this point, the Blazers’ last hope rest with NBA commissioner David Stern. Stern must find a replacement for Yao Ming, who is out for the year.

The way I see it, there are three serious candidates in Aldridge, Nash and Love for two possible spots. Deron Williams might sit out the All-Star game due to a strained tendon in his right wrist. Thus, if Stern chooses to overlook Aldridge for Yao’s spot, there still may be one last hope if Williams sits.

Stern has the opportunity to correct the mistakes of the coaches and reward a franchise who has had the worst luck. ‘LA to L.A.’ will bring back life into the Blazers’ fan base. Seeing their own in Los Angeles playing among the best of the best during this tumultuous season would be gratifying.

Stern, do the right thing.

  • Add a Comment
  • Share
  • RSS

Tags: , , ,

  • Stepfan

    Co-sign Chris Haynes. Do The Right Thing. A Spike Lee Joint, staring David Stern.

  • tRay

    That pic is nasty

  • http://nobulljive.com/ Enigmatic

    This is exactly what I said in my comment on the Andre Miller post.
    Miller should be heated Duncan got in, not Griffin.

  • brian

    can someone email this article to david stern or the nba.? ..PLEASE!!!!!

  • myke_bigga

    how about this: kevin love gets called as yao’s replacement, then deron williams sits out because of injury, and then LaMarcus Aldridge can take the last spot. But honestly, Aldridge is more deserving of being an allstar than Blake or Love. When you think about it, the allstar game is for either team or individual success, and OVERALL Aldridge has had more team AND individual success than Griffin or Love.

  • Spurs 74-8

    How do you make this statement and then say the man doesnt deserve to be voted in by his peers, yes his peers. No doubt, Tim Duncan is arguably the best power forward to ever walk the face of the earth. This is not some young gang banger or a classless juvinile spending his evenings at Strip Clubs. The Man is a presence and has the respect of every coach in the league. No other player is going to be voted in by the coaches over a future Hall of Fame Memeber.

    Im going to quote the Great Rudy Tomjanovich, “Don’t ever underestimate the heart of a champion!” and that my dimwitted friend is why Manu Ginobili is in the All Star game. The man knows how to win games in the clutch. Here are a few of his accomplishments.
    Medal record
    Men’s Basketball
    Competitor for Argentina
    Summer Olympics
    Gold 2004 Athens National team
    Bronze 2008 Beijing National team
    FIBA World Championship
    Silver 2002 Indianapolis National team
    FIBA Americas Championship
    Gold 2001 Neuquén National team
    Silver 2003 San Juan National team
    South American Basketball Championship
    Silver 1999 Bahía Blanca National Team
    NBA Championship: 2003, 2005, 2007

  • http://sdfklf.com Jukai

    Last time I checked, the all-star game isn’t ABOUT team achievements or lifetime achievements. It’s about showcasing the NBA’s best talents RIGHT NOW. So, yeah, Love and Griffin over Aldridge and Duncan.

  • http://counterkicks.com Quinned

    Thank you all star bid is not a lifetime achievement award, Klove and Aldridge should be in LA

  • First & Foremost

    LOL… you have only ONE line item that pertains to the NBA. If we went by world accomplishments Rubio should have been ROY for winning a championship in Europe.

    The All-Star game is about the current season. NOTHING ELSE. LMA has put up better numbers with a vastly inferior supporting cast.

    Someone please look up how many games Duncan has scored FEWER than 10 points.
    True Lamarcus scored 4 points vs. the Clippers… Then Duncan bested him and scored 2 points vs. the Lakers [The Rest of the spurs won that game]

  • http://www.need4sheed.com Tarzan Cooper

    none of you hoes are saying this about kg

  • MikeC.

    @Tarzan – Not as many quality 4s in the East. Lack of congestion.

  • ryang

    Tim Duncan deserves to be in the allstar game. Give me a break with all this aldridge talk. Hes so young he will no doubt be on the all star squad in thenear future. your article is off for this is duncans last couple of years. and no offense to those players you mentioned, but fans would much rather see duncan than those guys. As far as ginobili goes. he should be on the all star squad every year, no one except michael jordan is more competitive, and wants to win every night! all this whining about players not getting in is why basketball is a whiny sport. and three heat players is enough to make me vomit. Spurs fan for life

  • ryang

    this article was written by a laker fan ….. i can sense it. lol

  • ryang

    this article was written by a laker fan…. i can tell

  • johnny c

    aldridge, love, ellis, odom, nash, parker, z-bo, every name thats been thrown around on these forums and in the articles themselves. they all deserve it more then duncan. will they have legacies as great as his, doubtful, but currently they all playing at an allstar level, im not sure i would say TD is playing like an allstar this year.

  • cnewells

    Do the right thing. Good look Chris Haynes

  • twggyy

    ARGGG! L.A. really deserved to be there. I have seen him change and grow into quite a player. I have seen some manly stuff from him this year.

Advertisement