• September 29, 2009 8:00 am  |  66 Comments

    Top 50: Al Jefferson, no. 23

    The definitive ranking of the NBA’s best players.

    by Brett Ballantini

    In one of my first plays
    defending Shaq
    he dunked over me.
    But he didn’t just
    dunk over me,
    he took me with him.
    I wrapped my arms
    around him
    to stop his shot.
    Shaq just lifted off the ground,
    me clinging to him like a leaf,
    and completed the slam, anyway.
    Like I wasn’t even there.
    Welcome to the NBA, kid.
    –Al Jefferson (2009)

    Kevin who?

    OK, so the blockbuster deal that sent Jefferson, Ryan Gomes, Gerald Green, Theo Ratliff, Bassy Telfair, and two 2009 first-rounders (who became Johnny Flynn and Wayne Ellington) to the Timberwolves for Scowlin’ Kevin Garnett hasn’t been that pronounced a victory for Minnesota—at least not yet.

    Nobody can ever take away the ring KG cruised the Celtics to in 2008, so in truth, the trade’s a win for Boston until Al Jeff has two fingers weighed down. But there’s an awful lot of evidence that Jefferson is already a better player than Garnett. Offensively, Big Al has the edge, with a touch more polished than KG’s, more trips to the line, and big advantages in the ultimate hustle stat, offensive rebounding. Defensively, no one’s going to argue that The Kid’s Pterodactyl wingspan isn’t as good as it gets—but Jefferson is learning, getting better, and becoming tougher.

    But the No. 23 slot is not an opportunity to bury Garnett, but extol Jefferson. He was the clear prize of that July 2007 trade and has done nothing to evade the potential that found former GM-for-life Kevin McHale willing to deal away the only face of Minnesota’s franchise.

    Al Jeff is a bad, bad man on the floor, and every bit the southern gentleman off it. Consider: K-Mac felt the obligation to re-ink his new franchise centerpiece to a max extension in 2007—and Big Al refused. Rather than extorting a franchise on the wanAl Jeffersone, or angling for bigger bucks in some future collective bargaining agreement still to be negotiated, Jefferson took on a “fair” five years and $65 million because he didn’t feel he deserved more than that.

    An NBA player who felt he hadn’t yet “earned” a max deal. Big Al learned Minnesota Nice in an awful hurry.

    Also consider the tale above, told earlier this year by Jefferson, of his first meeting with his childhood idol, Shaquille O’Neal. Big Al has become every bit the superstar Shaq is today, yet he wouldn’t cop a gangster attitude and bravado his way through an amusing (and embarrassing) moment. Al Jeff being “real” doesn’t denigrate other players, but serve respect—with a side of self-deprecation sprinkled in.

    But the SLAM Top 50 isn’t the place to count Big Al’s Boy Scout merit badges or pat him on the back for being humble. It’s where he’s honored for being enough of a beast (his preferred term for his hardwood intensity) on the floor to parlay an ACL-torn, 50-game 2008-09 into the promise of being 23rd-best player in the League this season.

    At the same time, it’s sort of insulting to have to do so—what sound reasoning can be used to pin Al Jeff down at 23? He doesn’t have a sufficiently groovy nickname? His reconstructed ACL is thought not to be sound? The team jumping center around him this fall at the Target Center couldn’t beat the Minneapolis Metro Target Store Employee All-Stars?

    To the latter question, well, this summer’s Wrath of Kahn indeed decimated the short-term prospects of his Minny Mites. But as much as he tried, GM Genghis couldn’t tear down the entire team. Kevin Love, in spite of the enormous pressure Farmer Ryan Jones’s bromance places on him, is pure monster. You Gotham City dwellers think David Lee is something special? Love is to Lee as John Coltrane’s “My Favorite Things” is to Julie Andrews’. Gomes is no future All-NBA candidate, but he’s got enough Josh Howard in him to hold his own with the wingmen of the L. And Flynn might have struggled sharing a locker with Ricky Rubio in Genghis’ imagined fly-around-a-bug-zapper offense, but sans the Second Coming of Pete Maravich, Flynn will rock the point better than any Wolf since Sam I Am.

    Jefferson is, and at 24, should remain so for the next decade, The Franchise. It appears that he, and not Amar’e Stoudemire, is the spiritual son of Moses Malone, an o-board gobbler (3.4 per last year and well north of three per in his career as a starter) and already the 81st-best shooter (at .505) in NBA history. He’s shifted into becoming the centerpiece of the offense with aplomb, facing double- and triple-teams without a significant loss of shooting accuracy. He’s increasing his trips to the line, a sign of offensive maturity. Had he played enough in 2008-09 to qualify for year-end lists, his PER of 23.1 and Offensive Rebound Percentage of 10.6 would have tied him for ninth in the league, and his Total Rebound Percentage of 17.5 would have placed him eighth. Smoothed out over a per-36 minute standard, Al Jeff is a 19.3 and 11.1 player for his career.

    And it bears repeating how much credit Jefferson earns as a skilled offensive rebounder. Offensive boards are not a product of luck, or height, but pure hustle and court smarts. Statistics can’t measure pure heart, but the closest comes in the form of offensive rebounding. And Big Al’s got that number nailed.

    Humility is the mortal enemy of personality. If Shaq is Wilt Chamberlain, Dwight Howard may as well be Bill Russell. There’s no meaner, badder sweetheart in the League than Jefferson, which makes him who, Bob Lanier? That’s not exactly damning with faint praise, especially recognizing that Lanier is as gentlemanly an NBA veteran as you’ll ever meet.

    It’s Jefferson’s ticker that sets him apart. He’s cool, aloof, even jovial, but during that Great 48 every night, nothing gets between him and baskets, boards, stops, or fouls drawn. There are taller players in his games most every night, but there is no more intimidating man on the floor than Big Al.

    Shaq is now half-man, half-Jabberwocky prop. Dwight wears a cape, but sometimes seems just one slam-dunk prop from Terence Stansbury. And jumping center, who else you got? The list is thin. Al Jeff is on it, with a bullet.

    And by the All-Star break, surely our fair SLAM fans will have trouble counting 22 players better than the man from Monticello.

    Notes
    • Rankings are based solely on projected ‘09-10 performance.
    • Contributors to this list include: Jake Appleman, Brett Ballantini, Russ Bengtson, Toney Blare, Shannon Booher, Myles Brown, Franklyn Calle, Gregory Dole, Emry DowningHall, Jonathan Evans, Adam Fleischer, Jeff Fox, Sherman Johnson, Aaron Kaplowitz, John Krolik, Holly MacKenzie, Ryne Nelson, Chris O’Leary, Ben Osborne, Alan Paul, Susan Price, Sam Rubenstein, Khalid Salaam, Kye Stephenson, Adam Sweeney, Vincent Thomas, Tzvi Twersky, Justin Walsh, Joey Whelan, Eric Woodyard, and Nima Zarrabi.
    • Want more of the SLAMonline Top 50? Check out the archive.

    • Add a Comment
      • Digg
      • del.icio.us
      • Facebook
      • Google
      • StumbleUpon
      • TwitThis
      • Yahoo! Buzz
      • Print this article!
    • RSS

    Tags: , , ,

    • serevei Posted: Sep.29 at 8:05 am
      First,,,, GET SOME

    • larrylegend Posted: Sep.29 at 8:14 am
      classy player, not many of his kind left in today’s game.

    • LeoneL Posted: Sep.29 at 8:22 am
      wanna talk about underrated players? here’s one. hope al stays healthy this year.

    • Torrance Posted: Sep.29 at 8:23 am
      Wait, Big Al refused a max deal in 2007, only to take on a smaller contract? Whaaaat?
      Other than that, I hope he stays healthy this season and tears up the league.

    • G Posted: Sep.29 at 8:47 am
      Al Jefferson is not going to have a more impactful season than Shaquille O’Neal, imho.

    • Michael Posted: Sep.29 at 8:52 am
      well G, shaq plays with lebron, al plays with um…yeah. The boy cant defend but he is probably the most gifted player in the low block in the league, a bit of a throwback really. I like this placement.

    • DP Posted: Sep.29 at 8:52 am
      Mississippi stand up!!!! more analyis on the way later. got to run. play wit it.

    • Dagomar Posted: Sep.29 at 8:56 am
      Wow. This article would have been much better without the exaggerated comparisons with other players. Jefferson is better than KG in the post, but everywhere else KG is superior offensively. Jefferson is not nearly the superstar Shaq is today, and probably never will be. Come on. Great player (although a terrible passer/interior defender), good ranking, bad writeup.

    • neaorin Posted: Sep.29 at 8:58 am
      There are still some moments when you feel he should be passing the rock, but doesn’t. Other than that, no real complaints. Good ranking.

    • rog123 Posted: Sep.29 at 9:11 am
      Almost any nba team would trade their 2 and 3 best player for him

    • Brad Long Posted: Sep.29 at 9:21 am
      “But there’s an awful lot of evidence that Jefferson is already a better player than Garnett.” Great write up except for that part. Makes me wonder if you watched KG at all earlier this decade.

    • Bryan Posted: Sep.29 at 9:26 am
      Is kevin garnett still that good? Honestly?

    • Brad Long Posted: Sep.29 at 9:32 am
      I guess if we’re talking about “right now” there’s an argument to be made that Al may be better than Kevin, but a lot of that has to be based on how KG comes back from injury.

    • reidar Posted: Sep.29 at 9:49 am
      How come there are so many of the finest power forwards the league has ever seen playing now and such a lack of quality centers? I mean pau, kevin, bosh, amare, duncan, dirk, brand… Not saying that all of them necessarily are HOF, but hard to argue that all of them are real solid talents. Did Shaq scare them all away from playing the five?

    • Brad Long Posted: Sep.29 at 9:53 am
      Yes,reidar, he did.

    • rog123 Posted: Sep.29 at 9:54 am
      Why do we gotta bring this guy down with hof guy comparisons ? Juat cuz they were traded in the same deal? Then why don’t we compare ben wallace and sasha pavlovic to shaq

    • Mike H Posted: Sep.29 at 10:09 am
      One of my favorite players in the league. Hes so fun to watch, which is amazing considering that hes a big man.

    • Goat Posted: Sep.29 at 10:21 am
      Another good comparison would be Kobe and Vlade Divac

    • [...] Brian Scalabrine #44 Photos from Media Day Random Thoughts on Media Day Reports Slam Online   Top 50: Al Jefferson, no. 23 PME Newswire   OptionIt Partners With the Boston Celtics Celtics.com    Post Ups Notebook [...]

    • kobesbestfriend Posted: Sep.29 at 10:42 am
      how are guys that wont make the playoffs (or the allstar game 4 that matter)in the top 25???this is crazy!!!what is this for fantasy stats???

    • niQ Posted: Sep.29 at 11:08 am
      ^LOL@goat. So is Al J fully healed yet? It was sad to see him miss the whole season last year. Although Kevin Love got the playing time he needed to get accustomed to the league, I wanted Al J to kill it! And hopefully this will be the season!

    • airs Posted: Sep.29 at 11:24 am
      i love al jefferson.
      but this piece sucked.
      couldn’t make myself finish reading it.
      drose next

    • Allenp Posted: Sep.29 at 11:29 am
      Pass better, defend better, get to the line more.
      That’s all he needs to be a superstar. He’s got everything else.

    • T Money Posted: Sep.29 at 12:26 pm
      No complaints. Dude is the real deal.

    • matt the jazz fan Posted: Sep.29 at 12:32 pm
      the superstar two rankings down doesn’t defend much…

    • Anton Posted: Sep.29 at 12:34 pm
      Until you get injured you big cry baby
      Wait…

    • TADOne Posted: Sep.29 at 12:34 pm
      Co-sign Allenp. I would add that he could look to either bulk up more or just get cut and stronger, especially in his legs. He will be special for quite a few years.

    • Allenp Posted: Sep.29 at 1:03 pm
      TAD
      I could see him putting on muscle, but then I look at Duncan and I don’t know if it’s necessary. He needs to work on his counters and figure out how to be just as effective on both blocks. But, he already has a rock solid foundation. He has basketball skill around the basket that it’s very difficult to teach late in life.

    • jdn41 Posted: Sep.29 at 1:16 pm
      like holy crap why is slam on d rose nuts so hard…

    • Enigmatic Posted: Sep.29 at 1:30 pm
      “And by the All-Star break, surely our fair SLAM fans will have trouble counting 22 players better than the man from Monticello.” Yes, we might, and don’t call us Shirley!

    • tavoris Posted: Sep.29 at 1:45 pm
      Allenp, he’s starting to get to the line more. Offensively, he’s a pretty complete player-even if his passing leaves much to be desired. His skill and effort (are you reading, STAT?) is a joy to watch…

    • Jukai Posted: Sep.29 at 2:19 pm
      The write-up was a bit shaky, but the ranking is dead on.

    • Garett Posted: Sep.29 at 2:19 pm
      I agree with several posters, what’s with all the comparisons to other players? Maybe in a limited manner, but not to this extent.

    • tavoris Posted: Sep.29 at 2:58 pm
      Garett…the only player Jefferson can be compared to is probably Duncan. Just about every other post player in the L has too many holes offensively. Of course, he’s nowhere near as good as Duncan’s prime, but they are pretty much as wash now (at least offensively)

    • ClydeSays Posted: Sep.29 at 3:13 pm
      Jefferson is one of the best on the low block, if not THE best in the game today. The way he snakes through 1, 2, 3 defenders and scores is incredible. But his defense and passing have been an issue from day one. If the Wolves ever get a legit defender-shot blocker at center & a playmaking PG, they could be a force.

    • Mike Klander Posted: Sep.29 at 3:39 pm
      Great article. Even better positioning. This man is the next big thing. I sense a breakout year for this man for sure.

    • don Posted: Sep.29 at 4:05 pm
      and i bet Dagomar thinks he is a good writer.

    • 360vue Posted: Sep.29 at 4:15 pm
      but back on the topic of this article. probably a fair ranking, do respect this guy, a warrior! has a natural gift i suspect. however, not the best read so far, as some have noticed, but the point more than came across and ultimately, id say, thats what matters

    • 360vue Posted: Sep.29 at 4:17 pm
      wheres my earlier post?!?! blag! not reposting it… but the DRose hater can go swivel

    • ab_40 Posted: Sep.29 at 4:47 pm
      K-Mac for Kevin Mchale is the worst written nickname I red this year so far. ah well it is a nice writeup. How powerless must you feel wrapping around a guy and he dunks on you like you’re nothing. Glad I’m not an nba Big who thinks he can guard shaq haha. al is the seccond coming of moses malone if he averages 15 or more boards this year

    • Shem Posted: Sep.29 at 5:43 pm
      Piece sucked but i think al is atleast top 20. To address all the al kg comparassions, al is a better player now kg is a better player career wise. But al jeff does have the potential to be a top 5 pf all time when its all said and done. Hes only 24 and has averages of 19 and 11.. scary good.

    • jdote Posted: Sep.29 at 5:48 pm
      al jefferson… zach randolph… just sayin

    • Jerry Sloan Posted: Sep.29 at 6:11 pm
      Al-Jeff is like Z-Bo’s good twin. All the offensive post talent but people actually like him.

    • melvin ely Posted: Sep.29 at 6:50 pm
      The reason I think he’s being compared to KG isn’t completely because they were traded for one another. It’s kind of like, KG set the bar in ‘Sota. He was a consumate competitor (say what you will about his recent descent to insanity: dude was hungry to win all the time), he stayed with the team through their ups and downs long after other super stars would have asked for an out, and will probably have his jersey retired some time soon. To most Wolves fans, KG is undoubtedly the best Wolves player ever. Al is never going to be a 2nd coming of KG, but as franchise players go, you could go well trying to measure up to what Kevin has acheived in Minnesota, both community wise and on-court.

    • Brett Ballantini Posted: Sep.29 at 7:01 pm
      Very well said, Brother Ely.

    • Teddy-the-Bear Posted: Sep.29 at 7:23 pm
      LOL Derrick Rose ahead of Al Jefferson. This list is a JOKE. I’m sorry SLAM, great write-ups and everything, but this is just unacceptable.
      But, I think the reason for this is because, and correct me if I’m wrong:
      The top 50 lists are each put together by individual SLAM staff members and then weighted/averaged to make the actual released list. So, most the people might have put Jefferson at like top 15-20, but a bunch of others felt admonished by Al Jefferson’s knee injury and completely left him off the list. I still think its ridiculous, but, in that case its a little more understandable.

    • black pinoy Posted: Sep.29 at 7:41 pm
      rose is surely gonna do better than jefferson this season.. so yeah id defintly put rose on top of rose

    • MC Pats Posted: Sep.29 at 7:50 pm
      i dont think rose is on here but honestly why does everyone love him so much?

    • COLT6 Posted: Sep.29 at 7:57 pm
      Al Jeff is better offensively than KG? You high, son? Until Big Al learns to dribble and pass the rock like The Kid, he will not be better. But yes, on the low block the new King Wolf is virtually unstoppable having so many moves and gunnin’ it with deadly accuracy. All-Star. Better than KG? Not yet. Better than Stoudemire and Z-Bo? Any day, all day.

    • COLT6 Posted: Sep.29 at 8:07 pm
      black pinoy: Dugong mandirigma, dugong Pilipino. Itaas mo kapatid.

    • Bart Posted: Sep.29 at 8:42 pm
      If you want proof that my main codger Al Jeff is underrated you need to look no further than the comments on this site…. errr good placement 23 and 11 give me that anyday dude is top 10 legit

    • Shem Posted: Sep.29 at 9:02 pm
      Really though Rose had a great year last year, he is for sure on this list probably in the next 3 picks. Al jeff is a better player but you just cant have him ahead of d rose because this a list for the biggest producers next year, you really cant say Al jeff will have a big year coming off a season ending injury while d rose has the whole floor to himself next year. No BG, Deng isnt a prolific scorer, and dont argue that Thomas and Noah will average 20 anytime soon so I think if Al jeff wasnt injured last year he’d be higher

    • HT Posted: Sep.29 at 9:32 pm
      Does this mean my boy Monta isn’t making the top 50? Cus honestly there’s no way he’s better than big Al… but cmon

    • HT Posted: Sep.29 at 9:36 pm
      Is my boy monta ellis really not on this top 50 list? And no Dubs at all? Cus there’s no way he’s ahead of Big Al and the likes.

    • Enigmatic Posted: Sep.29 at 11:30 pm
      Let the speculation begin - “Where is Derrick Rose ranked?” “Did he make the list?” “Is he top twenty? Top TEN?”
      Been seeing a lot of D Rose hate lately. I think these are the people that hadn’t had a chance to see him play every game, and seen just how much faster, stronger, and more athletic he is than all the other point guards. Don’t get me wrong, Chris Paul is faster, Deron Williams might be stronger, but no one else in the L not named Lebron James has that combination in one player like Rose does. And he will be much improved in his second season. I’m constantly arguing with my brother-in-law, dude keeps saying Rose is overrated but has never seen a full Bulls game with Rose on the team….hmmmm….Rose haters, open your eyes and acknowledge that Rose will be a force in the L for years to come. Believe that.

    • vanillagorrila Posted: Sep.30 at 12:10 am
      I’m not so sure, everyone is so amped at the thought of a slightly more seasoned Rose without BG but in reality this year may be a much rougher one for him. It really is an unpredictable outcome will he shine or fold under the pressure of holding an entire team up with no close second. I expect him to have a rough time without Ben to dish out to and take too many contested inside layups but even if he doesn’t make a significant leap this year he will soon if the bulls can manage to snag another near star unless Deng improves by leaps and bounds

    • Z Posted: Sep.30 at 12:11 am
      Allenp, getting to the line more is usually what separates superstars from mere mortals. Passing better and defending better are no small feats either, takes time and commitment. / He has better numbers than KG and might be more effective offensively but KG at the 4 gives you a better chance of winning a game than Al at the 4. Therefore, KG is better. My rule of thumb when comparing players that play the same position is usually who I’d feel more comfortable with to win a basketball game.

    • Teddy-the-Bear Posted: Sep.30 at 12:14 am
      ^^^ Dude, people haven’t been questioning Derrick Rose’s potential for greatness at all. He’s becoming one of my favorite players to watch in the league. However, that being said, based alone on what he accomplished last year and what is projected of him next year (only being a sophomore), he IS overrated by this list. You can’t put a player who has potential to achieve Superstar play in the next few years over players who ARE and HAVE BEEN playing at a level of stardom for years already.

    • Teddy-the-Bear Posted: Sep.30 at 12:15 am
      And will continue to do so next year.

    • Teddy-the-Bear Posted: Sep.30 at 12:15 am
      That was for E, above Z.

    • jdote Posted: Sep.30 at 12:23 am
      no seriously… how successful has al jefferson been being the go-to guy… im not sold.. no disrespect. i know he needs talent around him, but man.. id take gil 0 over him n e day. gil 0’s the dude hes ten slots ahead of… and i dont quite understand the d rose hate.. y isnt there devin harris hate.. whats up with all these guys puttin numbers on below mediocre teams getting extreme luv, while guys like rondo and rose, point Gods of playoff teams, get hated on becuz they play with talent.. d rose and rondo could put up devin harris numbers (rondo would not score as much but have more assist)on a bad team… just sayin

    • Teddy-the-Bear Posted: Sep.30 at 12:24 am
      Al Jefferson looks like a mix between Raekwon and KRS-One.

    • cb 34 Posted: Sep.30 at 12:35 am
      @ z: KG is better than al. I’ll take him any day. Not only is kg reliable but he’s got the smarts to go along with it at both ends. Jefferson does have a polished inside game which is something we rarely see anymore. Even centers don’t or can’t play down the block like he does but there are just too many holes in his game. Jefferson will end up being like z-bo, a 20-10 guy his whole career but nothing to show for it except a couple of all-star games and a perennial loser. He’s consistent in that regard but definitely not one of my favorite players.

    • Niya-girl-fresh Posted: Sep.30 at 5:19 am
      Um, I don’t know about this. I mean he’s a decent player, he has his nights where he gives it on the court, but number 23 is a tad bit too high, well imo.

    • melvin ely Posted: Sep.30 at 7:01 am
      @CB34: I’m actually uncomfortable with you guys comparing Al to Z-bo. Granted they do have similar games, but attitude wise, we’ve already seen that Big Al already has a more sensible head on his shoulders when compared to Zack. I’d much rather compare him with Elton Brand than anyone else actually, but that’s just me.

    • CARLOS BOOZER Posted: Oct.1 at 11:23 am
      Until you get injured you big cry baby

    Comments




    The comments section is a place to further discuss the topics in this post. Commenters who seek to accomplish any of the following may be banned: - Personally attack other commenters. - Make derogatory comments regarding race, ethnicity, language, gender, sexual orientation or religion. - Troll, or comment with the intention of creating problems. Trolling includes, but isn't limited to, baiting people to flame at you, encouraging people to leave the site, spamming and using alternate IDs.