Wednesday, September 16th, 2009 at 8:00 am  |  109 responses

Top 50: Gilbert Arenas, no. 34

The definitive ranking of the NBA’s best players.

by Holly MacKenzie

Six-year deal. $111 million dollars. Two NBA seasons. 15 games.

Gilbert Arenas is watching. Reading. Listening. Creeping your TwitGilbert Arenaster timelines.

Oh, you didn’t know? You assumed just because he hasn’t jumped on board the Twitterwagon, hadn’t blogged in a minute or balled full out for the past two seasons that he lost steps both oncourt and off? Nah, he didn’t.

While Arenas will always receive flak from some for his outspoken nature, fun-loving antics and somewhat misunderstood ways, one thing that cannot ever be denied is his ability to connect with his fans. Besides his gregarious demeanor, two seasons ag, Gil had the tech side down. With the blog and his Halo sponsored team he reached bookworms and gamers alike. Opting to toss -and pay for- his jersey into the crowd each night allowed those fans in the arena the chance to connect with a piece of him.

There really wasn’t another personality like him out there, let alone another one in the same league.

When number 0 becomes the number 1 option in the blink of an eye, it makes sense that the man behind the number isn’t going to follow a conventional path. Conventional would have never worked with Arenas because it is the exact opposite of what he is.

He was a free agent who gave his team back 16 million dollars, signing for less than the max available because “what can I do for my family with $127 million that I can’t do for $111?” He was the rookie that would lick donuts and sprinkle them with baby powder before serving them to his veterans for his daily duty. The guy who once took a shower -in his uniform and bball shoes- during halftime because he was having a bad game. The son who’s room remained adorned with the Penny Hardaway posters in his father’s house even after he became an NBA star himself. The superstar who dropped 60 on the Lakers and has 26 career 40+-point games to his credit.

Bet you forgot that last stat, didn’t you?

While the past two years have been brutal for Arenas, thanks to back-to-back-to-back knee surgeries (on a knee that is now adorned with seven tattooed crosses almost seeming to serve as battle scars), despite his desire to keep his comeback underwraps, the hype is both undeniable and unavoidable. Thanks to twitter (shout out to you, @AI9 for starting it all with your “Runs at attack were pretty good today, gilbert arenas is back like he left his black card!” announcement to kick things off), a streetball game and some media coverage, the countdown to the 2009-2010 NBA season is also the countdown to the comeback.

Coincidentally, yesterday, washingtonwizards.com releasted video footage of Arenas working out over the offseason in Chicago with Tim Grover. Yes. Arenas is jumping back into the spotlight. He has to. Since he became a starter back in Golden State he hasn’t known how to be anything else.

While it was he who was the one to embrace blogging and have the title of the NBA’s first blog superstar, the way in which we distribute information to the masses  has evolved in the past two years. In other words, while Gilbert has a game to prove relevant, he no longer is in a small handful of NBA players sharing their thoughts with the world.

See, in the two years that Gilbert Arenas was all but removed from the NBA, the league has changed. A lot. Allen Iverson went from All-Star to an all-around painful storyline to follow. Shaquille O’Neal went from injured in Miami, revived in Phoenix and humble in Cleveland to appearing in an awkward weekly television show that has him playing other athletes at their sport. Stephon Marbury has gone from NBA point guard to, well, we still don’t really know, but it hasn’t been pretty. Kobe has ring number four. Adam Morrison has ring number one. Fact is, it’s a different NBA.

Arenas is a riddle in this NBA landscape that hasn’t quite been solved yet.

One thing that is entirely clear is how aware he is of the things that are being written about him both in print and online. We sometimes forget how media-saavvy he is because of the child-like joy he insists on playing with.

Prankster. Trickster. Joker. Take your pick to describe one who is forever young and having fun and you’ve got the beginning of Gil. From the blogging to the balling, the off-the-wall answers to the crazy antics that would leave you shaking your head, Gilbert is a player who has always worn a smile when he was oncourt.

Gil is a basketball player. Robbing him of that joy, a thief in the form of a knee injury has been the quickest way to eliminate that smile.

While he plastered one on when he was with his teammates, pushing them during workouts, games and practices and while he grinned freely as he suprised his girlfriend with a proposal last summer (that he tricked her into reading aloud to him, in true Arenas fashion), the smile that we are so familiar with shone brighter than ever in a two-game return this past season that saw him rack up 20 assists to just two turnovers and had people raving about this more mature Agent 0.

Just as the offseason hit and the news was that he was getting closer to being back for good, the smile was gone. Gil was gone. The voice we had grown accustomed to hearing was quiet. The blogging stopped as Arenas didn’t want to speak about his rehab any more, shifting his focus soley on getting himself right so he could get back.

As Gil was silenced, something new began to take the NBA by storm.

While this has been the summer of his rehab and comeback, it has also been the summer of Twitter. Gil may have been attempting to shy away from the attention for this offseason, but his fellow-NBAer’s ensured the buzz stayed on him through their twitter accounts. Couple the tweets with some streetball pickup games where Gil’s game was on full display, including drives to the hoop and a dunk to let everyone know he hadn’t left anything behind on the practice court where he had spent so long rehabbing and the countdown was on.

Yet still, the doubters persist. He won’t be the same. He can’t be. He’s a waste of money. Brittle. Weak. More concerned with having fun than winning basketball games.

To each and every one of you, peep the memo: He can hear you.

He knows how this story goes. He also knows how it feels to sit on the sidelines for not one, but two NBA seasons unable to help your team or prove you’re worth the money that team invested in you. Gilbert Arenas has been shattering glass ceilings and redefining any and all limitations placed upon him over his lifetime. This will be no different.

While Gilbert Arenas has “retired from blogging” and resisted joining the NBA Twitter army, he has remained at the top of the list for conversation topics as we head into this 2009-2010 NBA season. This is because his star is that bright. Two years removed (save for those 15 games) he remains relevant. Even with a drop, doubling from the 17th spot last offseason to the 34th this year, the words an optimistic Arenas spoke to SLAM’s own Myles Brown a year ago seem to take on more meaning this time around, “I think it’s wonderful to still be in the Top 50 considering I haven’t played in almost a year. So I’m grateful for that, but if I’m healthy, 17’s not my number.”

All reports are saying he is healthy. And if 17 wasn’t his number, 34 surely isn’t. With support from fellow Wizards teammates, new coach Flip Saunders and all of his fans who need their boy out there, the NBA is waiting to welcome Agent 0 with open arms. Beyond individual stats, a new-look Gilbert and/or a pass-first mentality, having a healthy Arenas in the arena every night is the goal.

While 34 will seem like a harsh ranking to some who read this and believe in Arenas and like a gift to others who think he is done, for this ranking it really isn’t about the number. It’s about the name. Gilbert Arenas is on this top 50 list because he is back. After rehabbing through surgeries, those seven crosses also serving as a reminder of all that he has pushed through, he is ready to start climbing the list.

And don’t get the lack of Twitter account twisted. Arenas will find a way to once again move to the forefront of the media game in the L. It’s just what he does. Connecting. That’s him.

From Zero to hero to hibachi. Or, something like that.

Notes
• Rankings are based solely on projected ’09-10 performance.
• Contributors to this list include: Jake Appleman, Brett Ballantini, Russ Bengtson, Toney Blare, Shannon Booher, Myles Brown, Franklyn Calle, Gregory Dole, Emry DowningHall, Jonathan Evans, Adam Fleischer, Jeff Fox, Sherman Johnson, Aaron Kaplowitz, John Krolik, Holly MacKenzie, Ryne Nelson, Chris O’Leary, Ben Osborne, Alan Paul, Susan Price, Sam Rubenstein, Khalid Salaam, Kye Stephenson, Adam Sweeney, Vincent Thomas, Tzvi Twersky, Justin Walsh, Joey Whelan, Eric Woodyard, and Nima Zarrabi.
• Want more of the SLAMonline Top 50? Check out the archive.

  • Add a Comment
  • Share
  • RSS

Tags: , , , ,

  • Atrain

    Lotta hate on here. Agent Zero gonna prove all doubters wrong this year and we’ll look back and say how was he only 34? Should be top 20…

  • http://slamonline.com Allenp

    Last year Gilbert was 13 or something, and he didn’t play at all after everybody saying how good he was looking.
    He might shine this year. He might not. Given his injury history, why the amazing faith in his performance.
    And to assume that because folks disagree with his ranking they must not be informed about the news regarding how good he looks is silly.
    There are 82 games in season. That’s a mighty long time on surgically repaired knees.

  • onlyclipfanonslam

    Should have been 50 if they really wanted to be fair. Like already said, it’s been 2 years. Old Gil is top ten talent. I will say this, if Gil is the Hibachi again I will make sure not to sell my tickets and actually go to see the bullets when they come to town this year.

  • Yesse

    This one is a tough one to predict.What if Arenas is as good as he use to be or even better.If so, then he has to be top 10, but its kinda safe to put him here for now.

  • http://www.mybleedingfingertips.blogspot.com/ Myles Brown

    Nice work Holly, good to see you back. And this ‘revelation’ seemed fairly obvious. If we didnt consider their past, we wouldnt know who they are. At the conclusion of the list all the ballots should be published for transparency and to stop the whining.

  • TADOne

    People will whine regardless, Myles. Are you new?

  • jdn41

    wow does this mean butler is ahead of him if that is the case this list is bs.

  • http://joeloholic.wordpress.com Joel O’s

    Good article. The League is a better one with Gilbert in it.

  • http://joeloholic.wordpress.com Joel O’s

    I don’t see why he shouldn’t be on this list. We’re looking at the next season, so his absence over the past 2 aren’t really relevant. Gilbert is back and healthy, and took his time rehabbing this time around instead of rushing back in. If Gilbert is at least as good as he was before, he’s arguably a top 10 player, and easily in the top 20.

  • http://joeloholic.wordpress.com Joel O’s

    And while many may argue that the past is the best (or only) predictor of the future, that doesn’t mean that it’s a good one.

  • http://www.hoopsvibe.com/christopher_sells-authorHV106.html chiqo

    the “different nba” paragraph and the last line are good stuff.

    so is it safe to assume that a player as talented as arenas at 34 means that no one is confident he’s really back from his injury?

  • http://www.lkz.ch Darksaber

    Haven’t written a word on the top 50 list for like 5 picks now, cause i don’t like the Nostradamus criteria being used. Plus even with an influx of certain new players into the league (OJ, D-Rose) and others who had surprisingly strong seasons last year (Rondo comes to mind)the core 50 of the Nba hasn’t changed all that much from last season.

  • http://www.lkz.ch Darksaber

    Gotta say though, TAD using the “are you new” line on Myles cracked me up. Funny Stuff, TADOne.

  • tavoris

    Darksaber, it was funny…altho I’ma have to get at TADOne for hijacking my line…this seems abour right (injury or not) because Gil is gonna have a lot of help on the perimeter this year.

  • tavoris

    cb…T-Mac can say he’s gonna be back all he wants. If he does, he will be the FIRST player to recover from microfracture surgery so fast and so well. Considering his injury history, I wouldn’t make that bet.

  • jdn41

    t mac is a scrub theres no way hes making this list

  • http://www.slamonline.com James the balla

    @BET, Eboy, TEddy, Jukai, Anton, Ryne and anyone else I have argued with about Kobe being number 1. If there are 33 better players then Gil this year in the league without him being injured. I will never post on this site again!!!

  • http://www.slamonline.com James the balla

    Hey does anyone know if DeShawn will be healthy this year for the Wiz? I want the Bron stopper back!!

  • Orlando Green

    Im a huge Tmac fan…but he wont be on this list…earlier today I wrote down 33 names that need to be on this list…and he isnt there

  • Shem

    TMAC is not on this list because this is the list for the top 50 best players for next season…. tmac is out half the season AND JUKAI please explain how allen iverson is better then gilbert arenas, im very curious to see how you come to that conclusion. KOBE WILL BE 1ST TO ALL LEBRON HATERS, YOU KNOW IT, I KNOW IT, SLAM KNOWS IT

  • http://www.manutd.com Z

    As T Money pointed out, it’s not because he’s 34th on the aggregate list that cats actually pencilled him as the 34th best player. Most likely, some put him in their top 15 and others didn’t put him on their list at all.

  • Andy

    Good article, but it seems like some of these rankings are just random in regards to this one and baron davis’ ranking. Because in both, it seems like the writer is unsure of how good they will actually be next season, under different circumstances (e.g. gil with injuries)

  • http://bballin_playa66@hotmail.com desmon

    Gilbert is a beast. Unlike A.i., he will lead a team into the playoffs if he’s healthy. If not, it’s like his team just added allen iverson.

  • http://hibachi20.blogspot.com Moose

    If there are 33 players in the NBA who are better than Gilbert Arenas, then pigs fly, cats have nine lives and I’m a stupid 8th grader.

  • ab_40

    so tmac is next right?

  • http://www.another48minutes.blogspot.com Gerard Himself

    ab_40: Read Shem’s last post, first line.

  • http://mbenga-mblog.blogspot.com/ vmcb

    I hope Gil’s back to where he was. Dude’s one of my favourite players to watch (and listen to). Super entertaining.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    Why do people think T-Mac is missing the entire season? He’s slated to come back around the BEGINNING of the season! So YES he should be in the top 50.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    I don’t see why Gilbert should be completely penalized for his injury-ridden season last year. The reports say he’s healthy and we all know when he’s at his best he’s at least top 20 in the league.
    Dwayne Wade is pretty much just as injury-prone as Gilbert is, but there are never any doubts or second-guessing when it comes to putting him in the top 10…

  • NC

    We’ll really have to see how his season pans out. I mean good read and all, but his injuries have nullified him. How you don’t lose something off your first step after such colossal knee surgery is almost beyond comprehension. Let’s hope he can pull it off.

  • http://slamonline.com Brad Long

    Great stuff, Holly Mac. This is a make or break year for Agent Zero.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    On a side note: Yao might be injury-prone, but he’s still the best offensive center in the league.

  • tavoris

    Teddy, if he comes back as an effective player before March, then he’s done something that Kidd, Webber, Stoudemire, KMart, and every other player who’s had microfracture surgery (at a younger age, mind you) wasn’t able to do. It usually takes 1 calendar year to fully rehab the knee after that surgery, and anoter year to regain a semblance of explosiveness. T-Mac with no explosiveness = Grant Hill.

  • http://hibachi20.blogspot.com Blinguo

    Shooting % …… made over a 100 million … shamed the game …. ruined how (((kids)))) play ===/== top 10 worst ever next to Ivey!!!!!!!!!!!!
    -
    He should adopt the attitude of Black President ’09. Still trying to hold me down, attacks don’t stop. Trying to reform his team, justify some already made spending. Keep it moving. New and improved Hibachi! with controllable fire to turn it on and off when necessary to smell what Agent 0 is cookin.

  • Joseyz

    Yeah umm he aint better than Allen Iverson infact the whole top 50 list so far does not have anybody better than Allen Iverson and dont be fooled be the Detroit situation. Even with the kind of season AI had he is higher than 34 simply because he is Allen Iverson. If this ranking is about how they will produce for their team next year im preety sure AI can probably do better in Memphis.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    @ tavoris: I’m just saying, its been reported that he’ll be back around the first few months of the season. I wouldn’t be surprised to see him in a uniform by November. Now, maybe he won’t be, but that’s what I’ve heard.

  • http:///realcavsfans.com Anton

    zero to hero back to zero

  • http://hibachi20.blogspot.com DP

    Back to hero, Anton. I have a feeling that Agent Zero is coming back with a vengance. all teams beware baby, my favorite player is back! Hibachi 2.0 stand up! play wit it.

  • http://bulls.com airs

    He’s one of the few NBA players I’d spend my hard earned dollars to see play regardless of the opponent. And he has to be feeling good, because he’s playing on asphalt on that knee. If he makes the All Star team, I’m copping some official Wizards shorts.

    But he still owes me some Gil Zero lows, because I couldn’t find those team colored ones ANYWHERE in Florida!

  • Solon

    Not sure about Agent 0. I mean two years ago when he was healthy, he is a top 15 player in the nba, top 5 scorer. But he just can’t stay healthy. If players like Elton Brand and T Mac don’t make the list cause of injury concerns, why should Mr. Hibachi? If your going to take a risk on a player that has had back to back to back knee surgeries, he should be in the 40-50 range. Saying he is at 35, means he is basically best or 2nd best player on most teams in the NBA. Questionable at best.
    Also-What about Monta? He was injured for part of the year, came back and played great by the end of the season-dropping 40 in the second to last game or something. Wasn’t he seen as a big time rising star this time last year? If Arenas is 35, can’t Monta be in the 40′s? He’s better then Mayo or Gay or Iverson. Yeah, I said it.
    And, where my boy Cap’n Jack? 30? Does he really get that much respect here at SLAM? If so-I’m feelin it.

  • TC

    top 10 this year…..watch out!

  • http://slamonline.com cb 34

    @ tavoris: I told you t-mac would be ready for the start of the season. Even teddy said he got the same info. I wish slam would give us an update on t-mac because nobody seems to really know what is up. As far as i know, he’s been working at attack with grover and looking good as ever. I got my doubts with him, just like with d-wade and definitely gil!

  • rikson

    Yeah, SLAM taking the safe road…. But – as mentioned before – Arenas will either be a top 15 player or will be out of the ranking, if its about next season. So pick one, man! To put him at mid 30s is…. well, weak!

  • http://fsjkfdlc.om Jukai

    Shem: Making a joke, buddy.

  • http://fsjkfdlc.om Jukai

    Anyway, I still think the placement is stupid, but you guys are missing some valuable info here: T-Mac and Brand (maybe) wont make the list because there is no evidence of their recovery. There is lots of evidence of Arenas’ recovery. So there.

  • rikson

    But there is NO WAY we’ll think Arenas is no.34 after the season…. I know that, you know that and slam definetly knows that too, so: is that a joke?

  • tavoris

    cb & Teddy, I’m aware of the reports he’s giving…and if TMac does come back so soon as an effective player, then he will be the first to come back from microfracture surgery so soon. Kidd took 1 year, and wasn’t only Kidd again after 2. Same for STAT. K-Mart was never the same (but took 2 years to come back). Same for Webber, Hardaway, Houston, etc…the reality is that 30 year old players with injury histories (like his) don’t have great results with that particular surgery (which many NEVER play basketball after). T-Mac said HIMSELF on 8/29 that he’s not comfortable jumping off his left leg yet.

  • big z

    the most DIS – RESPECTED player in the A.

  • Pingback: Jefferson adapting to a lesser role with Spurs | "Tell them … tell the team to bear down"

  • Pingback: Frye sinks six three-pointers again | "Tell them … tell the team to bear down"

Advertisement