Friday, October 23rd, 2009 at 8:00 am  |  338 responses

Top 50: LeBron James, no. 1

The definitive ranking of the NBA’s best players.

by Myles Brown/@mdotbrownLeBron James

The ballots were cast, counted, and a victor has been decided.

LeBron Raymone James is now the best player in basketball.

There, that was easy. Or was it?

It certainly appears to be a concise and declarative statement. But as with almost all other things regarding the great debate, this too is subject to interpretation.

What exactly is now? Just this very moment, as in right now? These present times and the foreseeable future, as in nowadays? Perhaps something tentative or undefined, as in now and again?

Time is of the essence in this industry. The past was once now and the future soon will be. Those who’ve aren’t willing to wait any longer believe their time is now. Those who aren’t ready to leave believe their time is still now. Problem is, no one knows how long now will last.

It’s no secret that each time we compile one of these lists much ado is made of the criteria. Is it based on last year, next year or an entire career? The answer would seem to lie in another concise and declarative statement: Rankings are based solely on projected 09-10 performance. But it’s not always easy to separate the three. Anything a player is deemed capable of doing in the future is based entirely on what they’ve done in the past. Being the best is not a proclamation, it’s a journey and destination.

And what is it to be the best anyway? Is it the most advantageous player, the most suitable player or the most desirable? We were spoiled for a decade by the unquestionable legacy of Michael Jordan, because he was all three. He was the most advantageous player because he was the most talented and fundamentally sound. Coupling those advantages with a keen intellect and an indomitable will made him the most suitable player to lead a team. The dynasty that ensued made it downright silly to desire anyone else.

Since he’s left us, these titles have been fragmented. But LeBron James could unify them and put all the semantics to rest if he’d just win a championship.

He holds a very special place in both the current and historical hierarchy. He’s the most ready made prep to pro player ever, who somehow managed to exceed the hype in leading his hometown team from the doldrums of irrelevance. He’s an unprecedented package of size, skill and athleticism, as close to a one man team as we’ve ever seen. While Kobe Bryant and Dwyane Wade have seemingly recaptured the essence of what made Jordan great, LeBron has redirected the collective consciousness to what is possible beyond that lengthy shadow. Triple double averages, Defensive Player of the Year, leading the league in scoring and assists, you name it. Nothing is unquestionably beyond his grasp.

Which is why it’s so maddening to see him fall short. He still hasn’t found the consistency with his midrange jumper. He has yet to shoot 80% from the line. His footwork is pedestrian and his post game is underdeveloped. These shouldn’t be the flaws of a seven year vet. Yet in spite of them, there still isn’t a team in the league that can truly stop him. Only four teams would even dare say they can contain him. But those four teams are what stand between him and indisputable greatness.

We’ve been at this for years. The awe, the anticipation, the inevitability of it all. For years he’s accelerated our expectations by exceeding them so easily, but the conversation has shifted from potential to production. He’s shown us he can do all but one thing. Every other year that it didn’t happen was nothing more than an inconvenience. This year if it doesn’t happen, it’s not only failure but possibly one of catastrophic proportions. In putting such pressure on the Cavaliers to build a contender he also put pressure on himself to produce a title. If he can’t achieve that in Cleveland, then he’s put pressure on himself to find somewhere he can.

LeBron Raymone James is the best player in basketball. But he has to win.

Now.

Notes
• Rankings are based solely on projected ’09-10 performance.
• Contributors to this list include: Jake Appleman, Brett Ballantini, Russ Bengtson, Toney Blare, Shannon Booher, Myles Brown, Franklyn Calle, Gregory Dole, Emry DowningHall, Jonathan Evans, Adam Fleischer, Jeff Fox, Sherman Johnson, Aaron Kaplowitz, John Krolik, Holly MacKenzie, Ryne Nelson, Chris O’Leary, Ben Osborne, Alan Paul, Susan Price, Sam Rubenstein, Khalid Salaam, Kye Stephenson, Adam Sweeney, Vincent Thomas, Tzvi Twersky, Justin Walsh, Joey Whelan, Eric Woodyard, and Nima Zarrabi.
• Want more of the SLAMonline Top 50? Check out the archive.

  • Add a Comment
  • Share
  • RSS

Tags: , , ,

  • Da Hood

    Basketball is all about ABILTY, say it with me A-BIL-I-TY. Let me put the disclaimer out there, I dont like Kobe all that much. BOOM, I dont care that he doesnt play consisent defense for 48 minutes or 82 games, who cares, but he has the abilty to do it, i dont care that he doesnt averager 7 boards a game, but he has an ability to do it. FEEL ME, Nothing is out of reach if he want to do it. He and D.Wade have most abilty in the League: offensive, defense, and intaglibes. Those three criteria are the only thing we should be judging on. People keep screaming bout his defense but no one goes at him, because he built a reputation on that side of the ball. when you do that dude are scared to go at him, ITS called a REP, when have one of those it does most of the work for you.

  • Nbk

    Basketball is about wins being a competition and all. Check who has more wins overall season+playoffs since 2003/04. And everyone who puts wade above LeBron OR Kobe has an immediately irrelovent opinion. The disadvantages inherent in wades game absent from lebron and kobes are obvious to anyone who watches more then 10 games a season

  • ka

    Brandonis Roypoulos lol

  • don

    Lebron is #1. yeah!

  • http://www.sixers.com 360vue

    @Da-Hood, da truth
    @The D-Train, ‘Brandonis Roypoulos’ is one THE funniest things I have read on slams comments in a good week or two
    @Nbk, what a needless diss of Wade… The only disadvantage I see in Wade’s game is that if he keeps throwing himself around the court like that then hes going to be in a wheelchair by the time he’s retired. Otherwise, its his fairly average 3pt shooting, which is much overhyped, or de-hyped. Throwing up 3 treys a game and getting one in isnt so bad, and changing your patterns keeps players on there toes so they dont read you like a book. And give the guy some slack, I don’t think he ever shot more than 100 treys in a season till the one gone by, which barely averages out as one a game. People used to say Jordan had sh!tty outside range, and he did, and look what happened there, worked hard and doubled his %s whilst becoming regarded as one of, if not, the greatest to have played the game… If Wade has any other glaring weaknesses I would genuinely love to hear them, because I don’t even you’ve watched Wade for more than a few games.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    The only disadvantage Wade has on LeBron and Kobe is his height. He’s 6-3, barely 6-4 and he plays incredible basketball.

  • Steve

    Best write up of the list. For me Kobe will be number one for 09-10, but when it is all said and done people will be talking about LBJ and MJ as the best ever, and Kobe and Wade won’t be a part of that conversation. If LBJ can develop a mean streak then look out. Right now though he is still too much of a nice guy … I get the feeling he wants to beat everyone, but he hasn’t quite reached the point where he wants to destroy them, break their will, make them nevew want to play him again. Kobe has that, and that combined with his game (which in isolated comparison is slightly inferior to LBJ’s, let’s be honest) makes him number one.

  • http://yahoo KEVIN45

    LEBRON#1 IS THE DUMBEST THING I’VE EVER HEARD FROM SLAM!I THOUGHT YOU GUYS WHERE BETTER THAN THAT.KOBE 5 RINGS.WATCH!

  • http://slamonline.com nbk

    Wades weaknesses that are absent from LeBron and Kobe’s game stem from defense. Wade gambles in about 1 out of every 4 or 5 possessions. His 2 steals and 1.5 blocks also translate to about 10 points a game off of backdoor cuts, or overgambling which results in a wide open three. He floats on defense like Kobe when hes gaurding Rajon Rondo, except Wade does it against EVERYONE. There are reasons that dwyane wades teams don’t win as many games as Kobe and LeBron did when they were on similarly talented teams.

  • http://www.kb24.com The Seed

    Lebron was put as number one, to make sure he is on future Slam magazines.
    Clearly he is not what yall think he is.
    LBJ has no rings and Wade has one but fools like Steve think
    he will reach MJ ok. First get Wade and to be honest his
    game is lacking, Lebron dribbling and jumper will always be suspect, that’s
    why he trys to barrel people over or jump into them. Watch when he plays a real
    defender he brings the ball up and lead with his shoulder to dribble, and his jumper is
    built on hope it goes in. I think he is behind KObe and truly behind Wade in overall skills,
    but thats just my opinino. Wade is the real gem, get him and Bosh for 10 and forget
    about Lebron. People will see his game for what it is and to be some great athelticly
    were is all of his highlight dunks, WHERE are they, I am tired of his one hand dunk and
    his hype has driven alot of people over board on him. Lets like the King they say, win
    a ring. The old NBA made dudes prove themself, now people make excuses for who you do or do not play with
    a la Steve Nash-2 time MVP. Lebron has gotten the hype, but STATS are great, build them
    up, but if he never wins a ring or just one, wouldn’t his career be a failure. Lets wait and see
    because like I said before. Orland is not going anywhere and Howard has a vendetta against
    a dude who can’t shake his hand. Here is LBJ career, ONe playoff highlight shot-still lost series,
    25 point outburst against Detroit, got swept in Finals, Crazy stats for the last 4 to 5 years-no rings.
    Will get more MVP’s because he is the new Steve Nash, these dumb sports writers, might give
    him a Defensive Player of the year for blocks from behind. but can’t guard straight up, but he
    is seen as number one NBA player. WADE will have a better career than him and just like Kobe in his 35 ppg year he
    should have got MVP, really WADE played with less a la Steve Nash and should have gotten MVP, Wade numbers was great
    even if it was a scrub team, still made playoff. Remember its MVP, not best team /best player MVP. Kobe will just have to
    settle for the MVP trophy of the FINALS again.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    ^^^ Dude, as much as people hype LeBron, you are just as irrational with your criticism.

  • Steve

    lol @ the seed. Bury your head in the sand all you want, but LBJ will have one of the most compelling careers from a statistical aspect ever. Rings are important, but people consistently rank Wilt over Bill Russell. If you don’t more power to you, if you do then everything you wrote above has zero credibility.

    Like I said, Kobe is number 1 for me next season, but long term, LBJ will be considered better even if he only gets one or two rings compared to 4/5 for Kobe.

  • Da Hood

    @Nbk Posted: Oct.25 at 9:57 am
    Basketball is about wins being a competition and all. Check who has more wins overall season+playoffs since 2003/04. And everyone who puts wade above LeBron OR Kobe has an immediately irrelovent opinion. The disadvantages inherent in wades game absent from lebron and kobes are obvious to anyone who watches more then 10 games a season

    Wow, what are you ten? Games must come on during your bedtime or your on that dust juice, Ball is a team game, Wade played some burgers last year and got to the playoffs, D. Wade is so much more complete than Bron is all size and power. Wade has actual skill beyond his phsyical gift, would we really be talkin bout Bron if he was 6’4, idk, he would prolly be just another dude in the league. When I watch Bron he has to work hard for every bucket(like dribbling 100 times at the top of the key). Arent the Great one supposed to make this game look easy. Bron doesnt Wade does it with less effort. Since wanna bring up winning, BoyBoy got a chip under his belt. Dont pull shaq out ya ass either, He singlehandly killed the Mavs, I know there the Mavs but a Chip is a Chip. I dont care if you won 30 games during the season, if you win the chip you still go down as a Champ.

    Young ass prolly don’t spit about Basketball talkin bout people opinions are irrelevant.

    P.S. Regular season wins dont mean spit except for standing purpose, How many 50 and 60 win teams didnt win the chip that current year? Oops, Bron was just on one!

    Out.

  • Da Hood

    I love ME some ME!

  • Da Hood

    And Yea, Bronny is my dude.

  • big z

    i hate people who hate anyone in the NBA.
    Stop hating on Lebron & Kobe they r both phenomenal players
    Stop with all the HATE

  • http://slamonline.com tealish

    @Big z: Sometimes it’s not about HATE… and more about… well, analyzing their respective games and forming an opinion on who you think is better. No opinion is necessary wrong per se, but in this case, one is obviously more correct.

  • Rog123

    If u block someone from behind, that is still defense. Its hustle defense. People make it seem like that is a bad thing to do

  • http://www.slamonline.com Ryan Jones

    This article would’ve been better if it had more quotes in it.

  • Cizzo

    Until LB23 win a ring……………….Kobe24#1!!!!

  • http://www2.gsb.columbia.edu/faculty/jstiglitz/ PANAGIOTIS VASILOPOULOS

    @Ryan Jones…..: i don’t think so, most everybody got your point(either they liked it or not…).

  • boogster

    @ big z without hating there`s no loving, you gotta pick your side and stand your ground, don`t live in limbo

  • boogster

    KOBE, teach Bron another lesson, play with Shaq you`re loser

  • OGSOLE80

    No knock on Lebron because he is great, Pound for pound for his size and athletic abilities… But to be number one without the credentials that Kobe and others have, thats tough.
    I think right now, Lebron is way more popular… But from a skills stand point, Lebron has a lot of catching up to do. (Not his fault because he is young) We know Lebron is putting in the work, but there are other guys outside of Kobe, that have better skills then LBJ.
    I think this is based on upside, which yes… LBJ has it on lock until Durant gains weight. But once KD puts the weight on, he will be in the top. KD is 2 inches taller then LBJ, and his over skills are way better the Lebron with only 3 years in.
    We cant put KD in the TOP 1 or 2, but I used him to show the value of Kobe… Kobe skills are on another level then anyone who has ever played the game… MJ too!!
    Sorry I know those are tough words, but even Mike lacked all of the skills Kobe has. MJ had an iron heart matched by nobody, and that got him to greatness… Along with a pair of Billion dollar bear claw sized hands.

  • http://slamonline.com/ Spaceship Jay

    Good Lord I’m late.. The only thing that seperates Lebron and Kobe at this point to me is Kobe’s vast amount of experience… and his knowledge of how to win. Lebron puts up massive numbers, with hopes that it will be enough to beat the other teams. Kobe usually puts up what is necessary to win. I doubt Kobe is going to ever put up MVP numbers again; but now he won’t have to. Lebron is the new Mike, because like Mike Lebron is something that we simply haven’t seen before. We’ve seen Kobe’s entire game 10 to 15 years prior with MJ. If Kobe wasn’t so odd personality wise I’m sure it would be a tougher argument. LOL, and co-sign The Seed on the media giant that is shoving Lebron down our throats. I’ve seen pregame commercials were they show Lebron highlights, and male Lions running across the Sarangetti!! And then the Cavs lose by 15.

  • JP

    the only thing Lebron does better than Kobe and everyplayer in the league is travelling on a fast break.

  • http://slamonline.com nbk

    Callin Dwayne Wade better then LeBron because of a title he won 3 years ago with a still somewhat dominant shaq is pathetic. I don’t care if his team was last place, he won a title once. Once again by your crappy logic, Darko Milicic has had a more successful career then LeBron James.

  • http://slamonline.com/ Spaceship Jay

    nbk, Shaq was still somewhat dominant? I disagree.

  • http://slamonline.com nbk

    in 2006? shaq averaged 20 and 9.6. pretty f’n dominant when you are still being doubled teamed every time you touch the ball on the block

  • http://slamonline.com nbk

    and deoes anyone realize passing is a skill? as well as protecting the ball? oh and defense? because saying kevin durant is more skilled then lebron james is like saying Scoring is the only skill in basketball

  • ab_40

    to here the word kobe including this is written 209 times haha. there was a lot less of a buzz around the list this year

  • Kyle

    “But He has to win…. now”

    Well, that’s good to hear because it’s not happening. So don’t worry, Kobe will be back at the 1 spot next year guys after he wins his 5th.

  • http://www.philsupplements.com drich_31

    You can’t go wrong with 1,2 and 3. You can put Wade and LBJ on L.A. and they’ll win it all too.

  • Da Hood

    @NBK I didnt bring winning, you did, i was making your point for you. This your quote “Basketball is about wins being a competition and all. Check who has more wins overall season+playoffs since 2003/04″

  • Da Hood

    To be honest, i dont care about any of these ni66as anyway. Im waiting for Gilchrist to go to the League.

  • Nbk

    Did you check who has the most WINS? In the end basketball is a game – 1 game at a time – compile playoff + regular season games since 03-04. I didn’t say check who has been on the best team. Like anyone would say it takes luck to win a title. Judges dudes on titles after 5 years w/ 30 teams is a cop out. Especially considering it is more about management then 1 dude.

  • rikson

    A real basketball player = No2 / A hyped athletic freak = No1 -> Thats whats wrong with the league!………. And I repeat: How can somebody be considered the best in the game, if he has no fundamentals like a J?! hmm…

  • Da Hood

    Since when did we start judging players for individual wins playoffs or regular season, players are judged by WINNING not wins , thats left for the Coaches to be judged by wins, players are judged by chips. I don’t make my case by bring up Chips, im strictly looking them as Ball Players, you wanna bring in odd stats to hide the fact one individual(D.WADE) is more complete than the other(Bron). This the last time I’m addressing you, cuz u making assinine and contradictory statements like this ‘Judges dudes on titles after 5 years w/ 30 teams is a cop out” And judging them individual wins isnt? How U sound, Money? I’m over this!

  • Nbk

    Wow your an idiot

  • http://www.slamonline.com 360vue

    1/2/3 are completely interchangeable depending upon perspective and interpretation. Although, currently, anyone saying Bron is a more complete player than Kobe or DWade are jumpin the gun, his ceiling probably means he will go, if not far, definitely beyond both. However at this time some of his fundamentals are really quite sucky in comparison, but hes still much younger than both so relax (1,000 days less than Flash) and of course some areas need work to match the other two because he’s been able to muscle his way around the court since he came from HS which is unbelievable, and almost unheard of! Its only natural he hasnt worked on some areas as much. Although you can’t really do it as its intrinsic to his game, try and take away Lebron’s unique physical attributes and compare the remainder of his game to the other two, and to get to the standard that they (Kobe/Wade) have to offer in most departments and its utterly apparent LBJ still needs some work. Meanwhile… Brons attributes that are stellar added to his unique athletical gifts all paper over the cracks of what he isnt much good at. All the while, the news media hype, supplemeneted by LBJs personal PR company (LRMR Management), Nike’s promotions team and NBA’s own efforts (MVP? You ARE having a joke) try to subdue you into accepting that his game is impeccable and near-flawless but it really isnt. Oh and some people need to relax a bit, its good to debate but some need to stop making all of this personal.

  • Da Hood

    Good Retort.

    rikson Posted: Oct.27 at 5:00 am
    A real basketball player = No2 / A hyped athletic freak = No1 -> Thats whats wrong with the league!………. And I repeat: How can somebody be considered the best in the game, if he has no fundamentals like a J?! hmm…

    BONG!

  • Da Hood

    My bad,NBK, I just realized ur right.

  • Julian McFly

    LeBron can have it when Kobe retires, until then he isn’t the best player as long as KB is lacing em up and knockin em down. PERIOD!

  • Nbk

    Al attributes that give a player an advantage to reason why he is worse then someone else is retarted. You qi never see lebron ply without his physical tools so stop trying to use that as a reason Wade and Kobe are better then him. If Tim Duncan was 6’2 he wouldn’t be the best pf ever, but that doesn’t matter he isn’t 6’2. Lebron puts up better numbers and more wins then dwyane Wade on a consistent basis. Judgin them off an event that happened 3 years ago an physical attributes that can’t be taken away is stupid.

  • http://www2.gsb.columbia.edu/faculty/jstiglitz/ PANAGIOTIS VASILOPOULOS

    come on, last year KOBE crashed 1000 comments easily as no-1, truth is that Lebronze ain’t KOBE but….not even 300??? Let’s hear it for Bron-bron!!!!

  • http://www2.gsb.columbia.edu/faculty/jstiglitz/ PANAGIOTIS VASILOPOULOS

    296

  • big z

    When LeBron leaves CLE.
    I wonder where he will go?

  • Dre

    People kill me saying Lebron hasn’t won anything yet. First of all Kobe won his first championship as the undisputed leader of his team… before then he was always Robin to Shaq’s Batman. Secondly all these short-minded Lebron haters are all probably too young to remember but most people considered Jordan the best player a good 2-3 years before he even won 1 ring. Now that Lebron is doing his thing and has a much more well rounded game then Kobe (he is becoming the triple double King) he hasn’t won anything yet. To all them I say… haters… please.

  • http://www.sixers.com 360vue

    Nbk, I noticed it earlier, but you literally interpret posts in your own way. So don’t call me retarded when you apparently can’t even read. Earlier you talked some absolute nonsense about someone saying KD was better than LBJ; they actually said only LBJ only has a ceiling to compare to KD, and until Durant gains weight, he isnt gonna get to the top. And I didn’t say LBJ is a lesser player than Wade or Kobe because of his physical gifts, and I also said you can’t seperate Lebron from his atleticism. However, in my view, you are genuinely stupid if you think LBJ has a more complete game than Wade or Kobe. You may view LBJ as a better player because he has a physical edge over almost every player in the league, coupled with some truly remarkable skills… like I said its open to interpretation as to what you want in an ideal player and who rank 1/2/3. But he isn’t more rounded than Wade or Kobe, FACT! Deal with it! Lebron is the most physical complete player in the League; build, strength, speed, explosiveness etc but like THIS VERY ARTICLE SAYS; his J is average, he has no post game, his footwork is par at best (which is probably why his post game is lacking because he has the technique and strength), hes not a great FT% especially when you consider he gets to the line often. And thats just what the article lists… Just because Wade or Kobe weren’t born with the rare physical nature of LBJ doesnt mean they are less complete players, in fact the opposite, they have to work harder to develop a more rounded game. Oh and like I said before, stop making this banter personal, its very childlike. Oh and yes Lebron has some amazing stats, testament to his ability, and stats better than Wade, but you are ignoring a whole plethora of factors if thats the basis of your argument; stats aren’t black and white when comparing players, there is a load of gray areas to contemplate too (Injuries played through, strength of squad played with, system played in etc etc)

  • Nbk

    Lebron skills aren’t as well rounded as Wade or Kobe – fact? How me the fact? I’ll wait…………

Advertisement