Wednesday, December 9th, 2009 at 1:28 pm  |  69 responses

Decade’s Best: General Manager

There. That was easy. Or was it?

by Myles Brown

General Manager of the Decade. Hmm.

This seems to be a no brainer.

But let’s not just hand it to RC Buford or name the award after him just yet.

The San Antonio Spurs are the League’s model franchise because they’re the antithesis of the modern franchise. There’s no bickering, no scandal, no apathy, no nothing. There should be little doubt as to who the team of the decade is, the Spurs’ care free consistency was more appealing than the debilitating drama-and questionable resurgence-in Los Angeles.  But in acknowledging that, we are recognizing the collective efforts of Holt, Buford, Poppovich, Duncan, Ginobili and Parker, Ballers By Law. Which of course weakens each of their cases in claiming any individual awards, and that includes Buford.

As for the other 29 guys, managing a franchise in this crazy business is a job few have long enough to achieve any measure of success.  Only a handful of candidates can arise for an award that requires such tenure and Joe Dumars would seem to be the next logical choice.

The Detroit Pistons were his vision and his alone. As was Darko Milicic. Is there a category for ‘Worst Decision of the Decade’? Can a GM conceivably win both? It was the right call to break that team up, but to do so in hopes of signing a player you should have drafted in the first place? Only to spend it on Ben Gordon and Charlie Villanueva instead?

That reminds me of the time I divorced my wife during a rough patch in our marriage because I thought I had another chance with her younger sister. I never did take that chance though. I knocked up two girls from the local community college instead.

This of course, never happened. Yet had it, I wouldn’t be surprised if my ‘Husband and Father of the Decade’ Trophies were lost in the mail.

Am I exaggerating? Probably. But you fucked up, Joe. Big time.

Problem is, the rest of the candidates pale by comparison. Kupchak and Ainge? Shrewd drafting, but beneficiaries of the two ‘Biggest Insider Trades of the Decade’. Donnie Nelson? Not enough rings. Colangelo? Smith? Pritchard? Presti? Not enough time. It seems whoever wins this award is also receiving more credit than they deserve.

Can’t we just wait and give it to whoever signs LeBron?

Okay, now I’m stalling. There are only two worthy recipients and I still don’t know who to pick. I didn’t-and still don’t- want to be lazy or presumptuous in just giving the award to Buford, especially since he’s essentially a figurehead or the representative of a triumvirate at best. Can you really be GM of the Decade by continually reaping the benefits of two good decisions? Yes, Parker and GinoJoe Dumarsbili were absolute steals the two Biggest Draft Steals of the Decade, but that’s it? That’s all it takes? Yes, there’s something to be said for moves that weren’t made and for the seamless integration of complements, but again, all benefits of two good phenomenal decisions. Group decisions.

I’m sorry San Antonio, but you leave me no choice. You can’t give an individual award to a group. Until one of you is selfish enough to demand the credit, none of you can have it.

Winner by default, Joe Dumars is GM of the Decade.

Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to check the mail.

***

For more Decade Awards, check out the archive.

  • Add a Comment
  • Share
  • RSS

Tags: , ,

  • http://www.hibachi20.blogspot.com Hursty

    Dumars fu*ked up. But he made up for it in a big way by getting Wallace a few months later. The Pistons arguably would never have won the ‘chip that year without him.
    Myles wrote a good piece and made a decision. As long as he sticks by that decision and argues his view – then he may be argued against, but you can’t just say “he’s wrong”.

  • http://www.slamonline.com Wayno

    good point Hursty. The Sheed Trade was deffinietly the reason they won, no question.

  • http://slamonline.com Jacob J

    I wonder if some of you guys realise that Detroit is not a place for big stars. (Example: Grant Hill, Bob McAdoo, Allen Iverson). So if he wouldve picked melo,wade, or bosh it wouldnt of helped the franchise (except maybe Bosh). Dumars is a very smart GM and he know what he is doing. You dont make the ECF 7 straight years,2 finals appearances, and a Championship without having a good team and GM. You guys need to see what happend with the AI and Chauncey trade I saw it all along Joe D wanted cap space for free agents this summer. It will pay off too it looks like its going in the same pattern as it did in the early 00′s.

  • Hussman25

    Im not even a lakers fan and I would have given it to Mitch K out in LA… This is def a default winner

  • roman

    Mitch Kupchak- deserved GM of the decade- How he pulled off the Pau Gasol trade is beyond me and I’m a Lakers fan. The Pistons have been declining since they won the title. Doesn’t the Pistons have Kwame Brown on their squad!!!!!!!!!!

  • dario

    love the article !

  • http://www.triplejunearthed.com/dacre Dacre

    Interesting reasoning. It’s almost a case of… ‘why DON’T they deserve it’?

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    Dacre, take your @ss back to the trailer and shut the f*ck up, racist piece of sh!t.

  • dmonz

    I have to disagree, It’s either the Spurs Gm or The Lakers Gm they have won the most titles this decade.
    Joe’s biggest mistake wasn’t Darko, (MJ made a bigger one with Kwame) it’s him firing Larry Brown right after they lost the finals to The Spurs in game 7 of very hard fought game (they even led 6 points in the 4th Q).. Larry could have guided Motown to a couple of more rings if Joe didn’t gave up on Larry right away..Big Ben would have never been benched and left.Flip was not half as good( check the Wizs now)and bad boys 2 never had a chance at the title again.. look at The Spurs and Lakers they didn’t give up on Pop and Jax.. and they’re the winningest teams this decade..

  • Sean

    This article is retarded.

  • http://slam shawn williams

    i dont know, he drafted darko! if he would have taken melo they might have 3 or 4 rings!

  • http://slam shawn williams

    i dont know, he drafted darko! if he would have taken melo they might have 3 or 4 rings!

  • MikeC.

    The Pistons as a franchise had to fire Larry Brown. Forget that he coached them to a championship, and all the players loved him. During the playoffs, against the Cavs, LB was consulting for the Cavs. Not only did he deserve to be fired, Joe D. should have challenged him to a dual. Give LB a little glove slap. Pistols at dawn and all that ish. You DO NOT fraternize with the competition. EVER!!! Joe D. gets and keeps my respect by firing the second best coach in the history of the franchise because he played footsie with the comp. Sports are a competition to decide who is the winner and who is the loser. Simple. You don’t get to fence-sit. If you try, you get fired.

  • J

    @roman: are you serious? and as far as i remember the lakers also had Kwame on their roster as a stating center a few years back.

  • J

    is it solely Dumars fault on Darko, or part of it is that Larry Brown didn’t gave him a chance? i think both. maybe, i said maybe, if Larry didn’t turn him into a human cigarette he could have been a decent back up center. cause that benching really sucks 90% of life out of him.

  • http://www.kb24.com The Seed

    To say that joe is best GM of this decade is just sad. One ring, the lakers have one, 2 finals apperances and maybe a 3 finals apperance. West beat joe at the beginning of this decade too. 3 rings 4 apperances.

  • Thom

    I don’t think picking Joe is unreasonable at all. As others have said, there was a clear top 3 in the 2003 draft, and Darko was typically seen as the 2nd best player available behind LeBron. Would it be nice to have Melo? Absolutely. But it made no sense at the time when Prince was starting to come into his own. We figured (correctly) that we had our SF of the future. Bosh and Wade were not seen as top 3 guys. In retrospect, they definitely were, but that’s revisionist history. Darko filled a need and was widely considered the best guy to take. That being said, Joe did what he could to salvage that pick. No one ever seems to mention the fact that when the Pistons traded Milicic and Carlos Arroyo to the Magic, they got back the Magic’s 2007 1st round pick along with Kelvin Cato’s expiring deal. Who’d we take with that pick? Rodney Stuckey, our current starting point guard averaging around 19/5/5. I know, I’d take Wade/Bosh/Melo over Stuckey 100% of the time, but it’s not like we got NOTHING out of our pick, and Joe was able to turn what could’ve been an abject failure into our current PG of the future.

  • Thom

    And to single out Dumars for that ONE THING as if it disqualifies him is incredibly stupid. Every GM makes mistakes. San Antonio doesn’t seem too happy being stuck with Richard Jefferson’s terrible contract right now. Kupchack almost immediately flipped the best player they got in the Shaq trade (Caron Butler) for Kwame Brown. Think Kobe couldn’t have used Tough Juice from 2004 on? Plus, the Pistons didn’t have a MASSIVE lull in the middle of the decade like Mitch’s Lakers did. Buford is the only guy that can match Dumars’ consistency, and it’d dubious how much control he’s actually had over the moves they’ve made.

  • Teddy-the-Bear

    Actually, I would pick Daryl Morey as best singular GM ni the game the last 10 years. Look at the team in Houston he has built–most players went second round or UNDRAFTED.

Advertisement