Friday, September 30th, 2011 at 4:11 pm  |  134 responses

NBA BATTLES: On Sale Now!

SLAM and 2K12 bring the barbershop and comment section to your bookshelf.

by Ben Osborne / @bosborne17

Cover images and inset photo by NBAE/Getty Images

Even if watching a basketball game is a lot more exciting than watching a baseball game, I have to admit I care almost as much about the latter sport, in part because of the way it embraces its history (insane nights like Wednesday don’t hurt either). The NBA, in my opinion, generally doesn’t do a great job of honoring its history. Ironically, this depressing, lockout-dictated offseason has seen NBA TV unleash an orgy of aged programming, but that’s by default. We’ll see if the League goes back to semi-ignoring its history when the current players are back in action.

As much as SLAM is concerned with unveiling what’s new in the game, from hot shoes to hot rookies to the next big high school sensation, I’d like to think we balance that by honoring the game’s past, with all our Old School stories and consistent nods to history. Given both my and SLAM’s interest in the game’s past greats, we absolutely love what the NBA 2K franchise did with its game this year (pre-order now!). Incorporating legendary teams and players that you can use with or against today’s stars is a brilliant idea that gets to the crux of what people like about the history of a sport: the chance to compare the past with the present. With NBA 2K12’s financial and creative support, we decided to do an entire issue dedicated to this awesome concept. What if Shaq had gotten to battle Wilt? What if an in-his-prime MJ went up against a seasoned Kobe? How about Bill Russell’s 1965 Celtics taking on Doc, Moses and the ’83 Sixers? We settled on these and 17 other matchups, featuring amazing players and teams, all of which are incredibly fun to imagine. And then we analyzed the battle and chose a “winner.”

Some quick words on how we (basically just the full-time staff; much like our Top 500 issue, this came together quickly and there was no time to properly get feedback from all of our great writers) chose winners…

For the players, we took guys who ostensibly play the same type of role on their respective teams, and envisioned them guarding one another in a five-on-five game played when each was at the peak of his powers. For current players, their peak might be right now. In other words, we did not imagine what guys like LeBron James or Kevin Durant could be capable of in three years; we went off of what has really happened in their careers. For the team battles, we only considered teams that had the best regular-season record and won a title, then picked what we think would be the most entertaining cross-era matchups possible. And then, with intelligence, wit and awesome photos (but zero science!), we had a lot of fun with this.

We may decide to post online in the future but for the next couple of months this will be a newsstand-only operation. And without giving you all an annoying, “save print” lecture, that’s how it should be. The photos are honestly tremendous, and the layout is sick, too. Sure, some of you may rush through a write-up to see who we pick as the winner, and we certainly anticipate some serious arguments amongst friends who either agree or disagree with our choices, but this issue is about more than that. This is a chance to take the history of the game you love from your television screen, your computer and your imagination and hold it in your hands. Look for it in New York this weekend and nationally next week!

  • Add a Comment
  • Share
  • RSS

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

  • http://slamonline.com datkid

    realistically lebron would give bird and magic fits… and if you whine to me about that 75 cents nonsense or him not being a winner you’re a fool. I personally would like to see lebron go up against the big O (oscar robertson) and mj as well. a prime healthy d.wade vs mj would be cool too, even tho mj would win that pretty easily.

  • EC

    5 dope match ups i wanna see. Carmelo Vs. Elgin, amare vs. kemp, Dwill vs. west, cp3 vs. zeke, vince vs. drexler.

  • http://jvnbatalk.weebly.com Jordan Valdés

    If we subscribe to Slam, do we get this issue as part of our subscription?

  • http://slamonline.com datkid

    lebron vs (prime)penny Hardaway vs prime grant hill vs prime t-mac! so awesome!

  • Yann Blavec

    Larry Bird vs. Dirk vs. Schrempf vs. Tom Chambers vs.Jack Sikma

  • Yann Blavec

    VS. Keith Van Horn

  • Yann Blavec

    Vs. Keith Van Horn vs. Tom Gugliotta.

  • AllOGNY

    Jordan, Wilt, Magic, Too early to tell but will probably be Durant, Bird, too early to tell but will probably be Iverson, Bulls, Celtics. Debates resolved

  • Jesse

    The Bulls were good for one 8-10 year period. The Lakers have had multiple dynasties starting at the end of the 40 and continuing into the 21st Century. It’s really not even close.

  • Jer Dawg

    I’d say most past players vs. present players would win certain matchups. Jordan vs. Bryant would be the only serious matchup because both them guys are 100% focused on tearing each opponent apart. Throw numbers aside in this instance. Some yahoo writer said it’s not fair to compare them to each other. I call BS because he’s basing off statistics. Mike layed groundwork for every 2 guard wanting to be great whereas the yesteryear’s 2 guards were too small and weak. He ate up Jeff Hornacek, Dan Marjle, John Starks, Byron Scott, Clyde Drexler, Reggie Miller, ect… Only Reggie Lewis and Drazen Petrovic gave Jordan hell. Kobe gotta be defending Ray Allen, Dwyane Wade, Allen Iverson, Tyreke Evans, Vince Carter, Brandon Roy, T-Mac, ect… all learned from Jordan’s approach. There was no blueprint back in Jordan’s day. Jordan IS better than most in his day. Kobe mastered Jordan’s approach while the other’s tried their best. And all these guys are super athletic. Jordan was two notches above the rest except for maybe Clyde Drexler athletically. This generation’s 2 guards are tough as nails.

  • http://sajkflf.com Jukai

    Jer Dog: Uhm…. Wade, Iverson, Evans, Carter, Roy and Mac are all lazy, uninterested defenders.
    Scott, Marjle, Starks, and Drexler were all athletically inferior to Jordan but they gave it 110% and actually cared about learning things like footwork and timing.
    I’d rather be guarded by the former.

  • http://slamonline.com datkid

    jukai wade is not an uninterested defender

  • http://slamonline.com datkid

    nah soulja3 ….prime inversion would eat d.rose alive… i really do think iverson was better at ALMOST everything you and enigmatic are tripping rose is NOT that good at defense either. you really don’t think rose is the best pg in terms of help defense do you? i doubt he’s better than rondo, cp3, d.will, russell westbrook, or jrue holiday. I wouldn’t say he was unworthy of that mvp award.. but he was definitely overrated lol

  • Will Lee

    Brian Scalabrine vs Brian Cardinal

  • haslem

    Jukai calls Wade a “lazy, uninterested defender” crazy. by any statistical measure wade is a solid defender, if anything his defensive flaws come from taking to many gambles so uninterested is a poor word choice.

  • Ali

    Time to get your debate on and fight for your favorite NBA ballers till your fingers are sore from typing, Hahaha…

  • DieselMechanic

    lol @ Will Lee that would be epic

  • marc

    soulja3 are you serious? didnt AI lead his team to the finals. AI is a way better contested shooter then D Rose. D rose maybe faster but i think AI is quicker. AI got this one i rather see him go against Isaiah Thomas and have D. Rose go against Kevin Johnson.

  • marc

    And i don’t know about that kd vs pippen. Pippen is a beast on defense so Kd won’t be able to the stuff he normally does. I would love to see that can’t wait for 2k12 lol

  • Jake

    iverson!!! way better than rose. he took a team of nobodies to the finals while winning league MVP in the first five years in the NBA. has a better jumper than d-rose and a way better cross. The only comparison is who’s a better scorer.

  • http://aol QGallday

    gottaaa!!! comment on that jordan/bryant matchup……if they both came in the league at the same time..jordan woulve killed him thru shear competitve edge.. he is the on;y offensive spark for his team and it proof in the pudding he dropped 69 on boston in the PLayoffs….sorry kobe…the last man to avg.37 for a season…..NASTY!!!!

  • MaxIsNative

    MJ vs OR

  • Kadavour

    what could Legend POSSIBLY do against Dirk’s post up?
    Magic can’t guard Bron, and Bron can’t roam on defense vs Magic. good matchup i guess.

    tmac vs Penny
    D Wade vs Drexler
    Iverson vs Zeke
    Garnett vs McHale
    VC vs Dr J/Iceman
    Nash vs Stockton
    Amare vs Ewing
    Ray Allen vs Reggie Miller

  • http://twitter.com/BeezKneezy LA Huey

    What about Webber’s Kings vs Nash’s Suns? Who you got?

  • Kadavour

    White Chocolate vs Pistol Pete
    Stockton/Malone vs Williams/Boozer?? – was i reaching on that one?
    Nique/Pippen (’94) vs Bron works better imo

    there are way too many matchups to be had here

  • http://twitter.com/BeezKneezy LA Huey

    @Kadavour, Shuttlesworth takes it against Reggie. But I’d love to see them chase each other around screens all day.

  • http://google J-RO

    Shaq vs Dwight??
    Iverson vs Zeke?
    Stockton vs D-Will??

  • Kadavour

    @ La Heuy, I dunno man. Reggie was such a crafty (dirty) player. I would love to see the match up too.

  • http://twitter.com/BeezKneezy LA Huey

    Prime Shaq would force Dwight into retirement. But Orlando Shaq vs Dwight would be fun to watch

  • http://slamonline.com nbk

    Pistol Pete should never ever in the history of basketball be so insulted as to even suggest to compare him to Jason Williams. Kadavour do some research on the guy. smh

  • http://cnbc.com JTaylor21

    I would buy this but theres one problem. HOW IS CHRIS BOSH NOT ON THE COVER. He is easily a top two all time power foward. I guess ill have 2 wait until the lockout ends and Bosh wins MVP for the world to recognize his greatness

  • jufu

    chris bosh alltime powerforward…hahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahhaah

  • http://slamonline.com Rocksinmypants

    lol@ JT

  • EtheKnickfan

    Wilt woulda worked shaq ass fellas. Stilt was in better shape at 50 than shaq is now. Dude went semi pro tennis after NBA career ended. Can you picture shaq returning a serve? Stilt was a faaaaarrrr better rebounder.

  • EtheKnickfan

    David Stern-VS- God

  • http://www.slamonline.com Slick Ric

    @ jake tripping, the eastern conference was the weakest I remember it to be, name one real good EC team from then, and A.I won Mvp his 5th year while Rose won it his 3rd year. As far as jumpshots, do people actually look at the number or just talk bs, his three point shot was better but Rose has been a more consistent mid-range jump shooter, thus, the fact he average over 47% field goal his first two seasons, and Rose worst FG% is Iversons best.

  • davidR

    kadavour, what can bird do against dirk’s postup? disrupt his timing, beat him to his sweet spots, and send him toward guards with quick hands to pick his pocket. bird is a smart player. if stephen jackson (who’s no slouch on defense) could void dirk’s offense in the playoffs using quick hands and smarts, i have no doubt in my mind bird can also shut him down.

  • manu

    @ Slick Ric….AI is 5’11….rose is 6’3……of course his FG will b worse avg PG is 6’2+….guys guardin AI were mainly SG’s too…..milwaukee bucks in 01 were as good as orlando, boston, and chicago today….so were the raps….vince in his prime, ray allen + sam cassell + glenn robinson

    lets see rose drop 48 in the finals let alone get 2 the finals

  • flash

    carmelo anthony vs bernard king
    derrick rose vs gary payton
    dwyane wade vs allen iverson
    lebron james vs charles barkley
    dwight howard vs david robinson

  • Sean B

    I need whatever kush this guy smokes^^^

    There’s no way the 2001 Bucks/76ers were even in the same stratosphere as Miami, Chicago, or Boston of this year.

  • http://www.slamonline.com Slick Ric

    well if you going to tell it straight at least give the whole truth, A.I maybe5’11 without shoes but with them he is 6’0 and Rose is 6’2 with shoes on, no big big difference.Really? the bucks were not as good as the celtics of today and the raptors would of been at the most seeded behind the knicks last season. individually they were good, but besides the bucks they would not even be quality playoff team in todays league.

  • Hart

    Wheres Brian Scalebrine vs Michael Jordan???

  • Diego

    how about J-Kidd vs Big O?

  • Mvpitzki!!!

    How about Dirk vs Miami’s big 3…….oh yeah we already know the result of that
    Then how about Kobe’s 2011 Lakers vs JJ Bare……damn same result

  • BostonBaller

    I agree with LA Huey on the Bird dirk matchup but I look forward to the write up. The Human Hi-Light rewal vs Half man Half amazing. Pistol vs Williams is indeed a joke…If you’re going to stay withing color then Bird n Pistol makes more sense..Dirk vs T Chambers. lol Tiny vs Wade…Pippen vs Durant vs IceMan

  • Mark

    Pistol Pete vs. anyone

  • Mark

    Rodman vs. Artest

  • Mark

    Shaq most dominating center of all time

  • Mark

    chris webber vs. kg, or amare

  • Mark

    Chris mullins vs. Mark Jackson

Advertisement